Tilt-Controlled Slider

#1

Post by mdznr » Sat, May 04, 2013, 7:00 PM UTC

About my open source implementation of the tilt-controlled slider found in the iOS 6 Music app.

Tilt-Controlled Slider
mdznr.com

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#2

Post by JD557 » Sat, May 04, 2013, 8:55 PM UTC

Looks pretty, although it seems a little bit excessive to me (others might have a different oppinion).

Just one thing: I think you would benefit from hosting yout videos in a way that can be streamed. Not everyone has QuickTime installed, so having to download .mov videos is kind of annoying

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#3

Post by danielamitay » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:01 PM UTC

Here's my implementation from June 2012: https://github.com/danielamitay/DAAnisotropicImage

I like how you're only re-drawing if the motion change passes a threshold.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#4

Post by mdznr » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:05 PM UTC

JD557 wrote: post #2

Looks pretty, although it seems a little bit excessive to me (others might have a different oppinion). Just one thing: I think you would benefit from hosting yout videos in a way that can be streamed. Not everyone has QuickTime installed, so having to download .mov videos is kind of annoying

Good idea. I'm uploading to Vimeo now.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#5

Post by mdznr » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:06 PM UTC

danielamitay wrote: post #3

Here's my implementation from June 2012: https://github.com/danielamitay/DAAnisotropicImage I like how you're only re-drawing if the motion change passes a threshold.

Thanks! I will have to check out your implementation. Has anyone contacted you about using it in their app?

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#6

Post by danielamitay » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:15 PM UTC

mdznr wrote: post #5

danielamitay wrote: post #3

Here's my implementation from June 2012: https://github.com/danielamitay/DAAnisotropicImage I like how you're only re-drawing if the motion change passes a threshold.

Thanks! I will have to check out your implementation. Has anyone contacted you about using it in their app?

I've found two apps using it so far.

That's the thing: I wish more people would notify you when they use your open source stuff. Attribution means less to me than simply knowing that it's being used.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#7

Post by mdznr » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:26 PM UTC

danielamitay wrote: post #6

mdznr wrote: post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Thanks! I will have to check out your implementation. Has anyone contacted you about using it in their app?

I've found two apps using it so far. That's the thing: I wish more people would notify you when they use your open source stuff. Attribution means less to me than simply knowing that it's being used.

Yeah. It's a pretty great feeling that you've contributed– not necessarily that you're getting credit for it.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#8

Post by biot » Sat, May 04, 2013, 9:37 PM UTC

  > Apple's implementation is also backwards. [...]
  > You'll notice that when changing the roll of the knob,
  > the shines rotate in the same direction (against the roll)

It's dependent upon whether the source of light is on the same or opposite side of the surface normal as you are. Try it again with the light source behind you and you will see Apple's implementation.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#9

Post by mdznr » Sat, May 04, 2013, 10:03 PM UTC

biot wrote: post #8

> Apple's implementation is also backwards. [...] > You'll notice that when changing the roll of the knob, > the shines rotate in the same direction (against the roll) It's dependent upon whether the source of light is on the same or opposite side of the surface normal as you are. Try it again with the light source behind you and you will see Apple's implementation.

You're right on whether the source of light is on the same or opposite side. I'm assuming the light is coming from above you and with respect to the view, in front of it. http://mdznr.com/bJ The way, I think, you're talking about is if the light were to be coming from the user's chest (certainly not what's expected and not in the HIG).

The part that's backwards about Apple's implementation is that tilting the device (roll) should rotate the shines and tilting the device (pitch) should change the size of the shines. Apple's rotates on pitch and changes size on roll.

Re: Tilt-Controlled Slider

#10

Post by biot » Sat, May 04, 2013, 10:50 PM UTC

mdznr wrote: post #9

biot wrote: post #8

> Apple's implementation is also backwards. [...] > You'll notice that when changing the roll of the knob, > the shines rotate in the same direction (against the roll) It's dependent upon whether the source of light is on the same or opposite side of the surface normal as you are. Try it again with the light source behind you and you will see Apple's implementation.

You're right on whether the source of light is on the same or opposite side. I'm assuming the light is coming from above you and with respect to the view, in front of it. http://mdznr.com/bJ The way, I think, you're talking about is if the light were to be coming from the user's chest (certainly not what's expected and not in the HIG). The part that's backwards about Apple's implementation is that tilting the device…

Coming from the user's chest isn't expected, but imagine a reading chair with the lamp over the user's shoulder, behind the chair. Same direction and a common scenario that I can imagine reproducing in software. How often do people place floor lamps directly in front of their chair?

If Apple's HIG says that the light source should always be directly ahead of you, then you are certainly correct. However, if straight ahead is 0 degrees then you can reproduce the opposite behavior (the effects of pitch and roll get swapped) by having the light source at 90 degrees (reading light beside the chair's right arm). The direction of shine rotation on the knob is reversed by having the light source 180 degrees from its current position (reading light beside the chair's left arm).