Live data from Hacker News

What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

philpapers.org

31–40 of 115 posts

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#31

A lot to dive into there, but the God results immediately jump out at me.

Especially those that answered "Other"...

My guess is Wiccan. Philosophers love their witches [1].

[1] http://www.uwo.ca/philosophy/undergraduate/Courses/2000.html...

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#32

In the question, "communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism", 40% said "Other". I'd really like to know if any one idea dominates here - for example, if 38% of philosophers espouse totalitarianism, that's worth getting into.

If you flick the setting at the top to "fine" you get a deeper breakdown. I won't paste it here as it would be quite tedious to format it here.

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#33

If you have a good understanding of consciousness / mind, you can derive the answer for most philosophical problems from that.

Nice, you almost managed to get a spit-take out of me for this post. I'll just note that the philosophers who answered this survey do not appear to agree with you.

Yes, I'm aware that majority of people don't agree with my philosophical views, but I think they're pretty rational, not the usual philosophical babble :)

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#35
post #32

In the question, "communitarianism, egalitarianism, or libertarianism", 40% said "Other". I'd really like to know if any one idea dominates here - for example, if 38% of philosophers espouse totalitarianism, that's worth getting into.

If you flick the setting at the top to "fine" you get a deeper breakdown. I won't paste it here as it would be quite tedious to format it here.

Tl;dr: they're distributed among "unclear", "more than one", "intermediate view" and so on.

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#37
post #4

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That is a big IF. If I had a million dollars, I could buy your love.

I think I have a relatively good understanding of consciousness: * Content of consciousness is the only thing that we can be sure of. Let's say I'm scared. This fact is true no matter if I'm in a dream or hallucinating. (We could argue if "scared" is the correct label for the feeling but that's not the point.) * It's impossible to define consciousness objectively. Subjective definition is simple: Consciousness is my…

>Content of consciousness is the only thing that we can be sure of. Let's say I'm scared. This fact is true no matter if I'm in a dream or hallucinating.

I admire your confidence.

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#39
Here's one of my favorites. Glad to see the pros are evenly split, because this one really toasts my brain too.

Teletransporter (new matter): survival or death?

Accept or lean toward: survival 337 / 931 (36.2%) Other 304 / 931 (32.7%) Accept or lean toward: death 290 / 931 (31.1%)

Re: What professional philosophers believe – Survey results

#40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nice, you almost managed to get a spit-take out of me for this post. I'll just note that the philosophers who answered this survey do not appear to agree with you.

Yes, I'm aware that majority of people don't agree with my philosophical views, but I think they're pretty rational, not the usual philosophical babble :)

Your prejudice is showing. Philosophy is about knowing and reasoning about reality. There are charlatans who try to pass off their weak ideas through obfuscation, but there is a core to the endeavor of philosophy, and good philosophers out there making noteworthy observations about reality.
Post reply on HN