Live data from Hacker News

Manchester City Council

manchester.gov.uk

21–30 of 234 posts

Re: Manchester City Council

#21
post #14
post #7

I'm sure everyone else is aware of how local government websites look in their own parts of the world - but for a similar-sized UK city Edinburgh City Council's website is a good (i.e. bad) example for comparison: http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk

I really dislike the archaic/gothic use of 'V' rather than 'U' - it looks pretentious and always makes me read it twice before remembering the usage.

That's not really the fault of the website - as far as I know it's part of the brand for Edinburgh Council.

Re: Manchester City Council

#22
post #16

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why should public services be ugly?

They should be if it's cheaper (while still meeting the goals etc).

What correlation is there between expensive design and good design?

I've seen projects that haven't cost more than a few hundred dollars and still look absolutely stunning. I've also seen projects developed this year that look like they have been dragged from the 90s, yet cost millions in today's money.

Re: Manchester City Council

#25
Looking past the knee-jerk reaction to "this design looks expensive", would love to see how the Manchester Council site performs from a service design perspective. How do local residents use the site? Can they find what they need quickly and easily, from both a desktop and a mobile?

I'm betting yes, and the cost saved (in terms of time, frustration and maybe money) over a poorly designed yet inexpensive-looking site will be worthwhile.

Side note: Would love to see a blog post about the thought behind the design, either from the design agency or the web manager at Manchester...

Re: Manchester City Council

#26
post #2

Similar: https://www.gov.uk/ http://storify.com/GovUK/gov-uk-wins-design-of-the-year-awar...

Holy hell, I've been going through accountants and the HMRC and things for years and nobody has been able to answer me and tell me what this page told me in two clicks!

https://www.gov.uk/running-a-limited-company/taking-money-ou...

That is brilliant, thank you very much for this.

Re: Manchester City Council

#27
post #7

I'm sure everyone else is aware of how local government websites look in their own parts of the world - but for a similar-sized UK city Edinburgh City Council's website is a good (i.e. bad) example for comparison: http://www.edinburgh.gov.uk

I honestly don't mind the Edinburgh site - I'd rather they focus on content and functionality rather than changing it every year to comply with the latest design fad.

True but nobody's saying they should - it's just a good example of a cluttered and disorganised website
Post reply on HN