Live data from Hacker News

Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

businessinsider.com

11–20 of 52 posts

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#11
post #9

Why doesn't Google just provide a tool to import a user's full Facebook data into Google+ with a single click? They could even do it without the user's consent for people using Chrome or Android, or they could pay people to do so (it might cost them 10 billions, but it would be quite a good "company" to "acquire"). Without doing that, or having some killer feature, there's no way that they will take off.

Facebook has a long history of disabling that sort of system.

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#13
post #9

Why doesn't Google just provide a tool to import a user's full Facebook data into Google+ with a single click? They could even do it without the user's consent for people using Chrome or Android, or they could pay people to do so (it might cost them 10 billions, but it would be quite a good "company" to "acquire"). Without doing that, or having some killer feature, there's no way that they will take off.

Facebook has a long history of disabling that sort of system.

Uh? That's impossible to do.

Facebook already provides a way to download all your data, so Google just needs to write software that uses it and uploads it into Google+.

Alternatively, they can just automatically scrape the Facebook website via HTTP directly from the user's machine (using a modified Chrome, modified Android, desktop tool or Android app).

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#15
I love it, I use Twitter, I used Facebook. Circles just does it for me.

I care about these people today, I want to follow circle XYZ, I want to share this to Mates, Nerds, Android, etc.

The Photo Albums is amazing and linked up with Instant Upload from my phone at full res when charging on a WiFi.

I really like Google+ and wish it had come out before Twitter/Facebook.

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#16

The only feature of Google+ that is really interesting to me is hangouts. That is a social thing that I use at work almost every day, but it doesn't really fit the traditional social network model, and it doesn't help Google make advertising money.

Sounds to me like it's a prime candidate for some of Google's famed "spring cleaning" in the coming years...

That would be fine, and Google should still be lauded. Hangout started a whole cottage industry, and also nudged existing video chat vendors to adopt Hangout like functionality. If Google shut down Hangout, I would miss how reliable and high-quality it is compared to Skype, but there are a couple good alternatives now.

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#17
A lot of skeptics here (as usual!)

Well I use both Google+ and Facebook every day and to me Google+ seems VERY active with a lot of high quality content as well.

I can't really say if it is more active than Twitter (which is also very active of course) but it certainly doesn't seem like "a ghost town" as some people try to claim.

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Facebook has a long history of disabling that sort of system.

Uh? That's impossible to do. Facebook already provides a way to download all your data, so Google just needs to write software that uses it and uploads it into Google+. Alternatively, they can just automatically scrape the Facebook website via HTTP directly from the user's machine (using a modified Chrome, modified Android, desktop tool or Android app).

Scoble was banned from Facebook because he was scraping contact info. I'm fairly certain it's a violation of their Terms of Service.

Given that that's unlawful access of a computer system (and kind of a dick move,) I don't think Google wants to go down that route.

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#19
Well, i hope so. I still don't get the value of twitter, it always seemed to me as overrated. Why 140 characters? External services for photo upload? I still don't get it..

How is [1] better then [2]?!

[1] http://www.imagebanana.com/view/okt9mdpq/obamatwitter.png [2] http://www.imagebanana.com/view/ma3vuvby/obamagooglep.png

I hope i don't start a religious war now, just saying although i have a twitter account i never really got to use it...

edit: changed screenshots to english versions

Re: Google+ Is Outpacing Twitter

#20
I know the numbers are inflated due to tie-in with other Google services, but I'm very optimistic about Google+ long term.

I got my invite in the first wave and pretty much immediately ditched the service. I just didn't see why I'd use it. I am a light Facebook user and I don't Tweet.

Recently I decided to give G+ another try and I love what I am seeing. First of all, the site is a pleasure to use and the mobile app is by far best in class. Second, I think G+ is absolutely the best social network for those who are interested in following people outside of their friends. Celebrities on Facebook have something to sell, and on Twitter there's not enough room, but on G+ I get long, interesting posts from famous people around the world.

I only have a few friends on G+ but I am starting to check it more and more and I can say without a doubt that if it ever hits critical mass I'll be the first to drop Facebook. Google simply has the latecomer's advantage, they got to watch Facebook stumble and build around those obstacles at their own pace.

Also, Google+ sign-in is a great developer product. The deep-linking concept is a very interesting implementation of sharing for mobile apps that borrows from Android's intent system.

Post reply on HN