Live data from Hacker News

Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

torrentfreak.com

11–20 of 126 posts

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#11
post #6

Can they actually hold off collective might of media houses and billionaires who actually call the shots and make politicians dance to their tunes, mostly because of they have taken the dirty money? What if the bullies resort to proxy arm twisting? One must remember Iceland was invaded[1] by the British during WW2! PS. An invasion is an invasion even if it was said that the invasion was to pre-empt another invasion.…

[deleted]

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#12
post #10
post #6

Can they actually hold off collective might of media houses and billionaires who actually call the shots and make politicians dance to their tunes, mostly because of they have taken the dirty money? What if the bullies resort to proxy arm twisting? One must remember Iceland was invaded[1] by the British during WW2! PS. An invasion is an invasion even if it was said that the invasion was to pre-empt another invasion.…

I doubt anyone's going to invade Iceland because of TPB.

I'm sure something more subtle would be used - like delaying their application for EU membership, which is currently in the works.

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#13

It seems the switch to a new domain name has broken the ISP censorship in the UK. thepiratebay.se redirects to a site blocked page. thepiratebay.is works. I'm sure it won't be long until they block it again but this domain change as well as the numerous proxy sites setup to bypass the block go to show that it's a waste of time to even try blocking stuff like this. Does anyone know if the ISP's will be automatically r…

I'm on Virgin Media (UK) and thepiratebay.is doesn't work here. This implies that they don't have to go through the court. I suspect if the new domain is being run by the same organisation they are required to block instantly. I wonder what the legal issues are if The Pirate Bay splits into multipel organisations hosted on different domains.

There's now a (court approved) process that doesn't involve going to court for each domain, it's simply added to the block list.

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#14
post #6

Can they actually hold off collective might of media houses and billionaires who actually call the shots and make politicians dance to their tunes, mostly because of they have taken the dirty money? What if the bullies resort to proxy arm twisting? One must remember Iceland was invaded[1] by the British during WW2! PS. An invasion is an invasion even if it was said that the invasion was to pre-empt another invasion.…

I'm not really sure it's bullying per se, to try and stop the mass illegal downloading of your content. It's not like they've got thugs at the door, they're just trying to shut down a site who's sole purpose is enabling the illegal downloading, and who has no interest in co-operating with even nicely worded, fair requests. I'm not a great fan of the entertainment industry, but if people were doing this to YC startups who focus on IP production, would the level of "support" be the same?

I mean, what alternative do people suggest for these companies? That they ignore it, thus tacitly approve it, until everyone uses and doesn't bother with legal avenues? I hear a lot about "Well, find a new business model!", without explaining why a company should be forced to change based on clearly illegal activity. Even accepting the pragmatic argument that "It's going to happen anyway", I'm curious as to what business model people are suggesting?

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#15
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I doubt anyone's going to invade Iceland because of TPB.

I'm sure something more subtle would be used - like delaying their application for EU membership, which is currently in the works.

Most Icelanders do not want to join the EU. The two political parties with the current greatest following which will probably be elected for a new government next Saturday also oppose joining the EU.

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#16

It seems the switch to a new domain name has broken the ISP censorship in the UK. thepiratebay.se redirects to a site blocked page. thepiratebay.is works. I'm sure it won't be long until they block it again but this domain change as well as the numerous proxy sites setup to bypass the block go to show that it's a waste of time to even try blocking stuff like this. Does anyone know if the ISP's will be automatically r…

You should probably switch to an ISP that doesn't filter. Mine doesn't.

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#17
post #6

Can they actually hold off collective might of media houses and billionaires who actually call the shots and make politicians dance to their tunes, mostly because of they have taken the dirty money? What if the bullies resort to proxy arm twisting? One must remember Iceland was invaded[1] by the British during WW2! PS. An invasion is an invasion even if it was said that the invasion was to pre-empt another invasion.…

[deleted]

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm on Virgin Media (UK) and thepiratebay.is doesn't work here. This implies that they don't have to go through the court. I suspect if the new domain is being run by the same organisation they are required to block instantly. I wonder what the legal issues are if The Pirate Bay splits into multipel organisations hosted on different domains.

There's now a (court approved) process that doesn't involve going to court for each domain, it's simply added to the block list.

Is the list publicly available ?

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#19
post #16

It seems the switch to a new domain name has broken the ISP censorship in the UK. thepiratebay.se redirects to a site blocked page. thepiratebay.is works. I'm sure it won't be long until they block it again but this domain change as well as the numerous proxy sites setup to bypass the block go to show that it's a waste of time to even try blocking stuff like this. Does anyone know if the ISP's will be automatically r…

You should probably switch to an ISP that doesn't filter. Mine doesn't.

May I ask which one you're with?

Re: Pirate Bay Finds Safe Haven in Iceland, Switches to .IS Domain

#20
post #18
post #13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's now a (court approved) process that doesn't involve going to court for each domain, it's simply added to the block list.

Is the list publicly available ?

No I don't believe so, the original "source sites" are all done by court order, so people like ORG have reported on them, but clone sites, and new DNS names for existing sites, are simply blocked by request of the BPI.

"Once a site is blocked, its alleged clone sites can also be blocked, but in this case, BPI will be able to practice this without a court order. The decisions would be made between BPI and ISPs and will not be published."

http://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/2013/bpi-fenopy-block

Post reply on HN