Live data from Hacker News

BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

torrentfreak.com

201–210 of 291 posts

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#201
post #126

Creating an AMI wired to s3 seems like an obvious next step.

We (rsync.net) will implement this on our storage arrays, provided it can run over SSH in some capacity. That way you can target rsync.net space with BS. We already do this with git-annex.

That sound great!

I'm building a backup service for sql server, and wonder if this route could be better than rsync?

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#202
post #135
post #9

Really nice, but the thing is... Dropbox has gone beyond just file sharing. One example: I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. I moved from Flickr to Picasa as it could cope with the directories full of photos and I didn't have to manually upload them and Google's storage space was cheaper. Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where…

If you are a photographer, Our Tonido ( http://www.tonido.com ) solution is simply perfect. It is not expensive as dropbox, and no storage limits, supports variety of photo formats (JPEG, PNG, GIF, CR2, NEF, CRW and more). As dropbox, we have good mobile apps for all the popular platforms. Pretty much majority of our paid users are photographers.

I think for photographers, the backup functionality of most "sharing" sites is pretty important... and Tonido seems to not address that at all (by design).

It still looks like an interesting product, mind you...

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#203
post #171
post #34

Earlier quoted context omitted.

From the article: > While Sync uses BitTorrent technology, people’s files are not accessible to outsiders. Only those who have the unique private key can access the shared folder. > > “All the traffic is encrypted using a private key derived from the shared secret. Your files can be viewed and received only by the people with whom you share your private secret,” BitTorrent explains.

Security wise, is this that different from just making a private torrent yourself and giving it to someone you know?

It’s equivalent of making a private torrent of your encrypted content then giving your friend the torrent metadata AND decryption key. That is not including additional features.

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#204
post #159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Why? How is the government going to shut down what is basically a private decentralized p2p network? There isn't any central server they can take out and the traffic over the network would look like any other encrypted traffic. If they gained access to the sync group with full permissions they could destroy it and get IP addresses, etc. And the format itself might not lend itself to all the needs of a political activ…

It would look like any other encrypted information, but I'm unsure that the traffic patterns themselves wouldn't be distinctive.

Not the point of the use-case. And obviously Tor could be added to the mix.

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#205
post #9

Really nice, but the thing is... Dropbox has gone beyond just file sharing. One example: I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. I moved from Flickr to Picasa as it could cope with the directories full of photos and I didn't have to manually upload them and Google's storage space was cheaper. Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where…

> Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where next?

Uhm... how about the 200 GB plan? Or the 400 GB plan. Or 1 TB for $49.99/month? Or you could contact sales about Google Cloud Storage: https://cloud.google.com/pricing/cloud-storage Or you could just buy S3 storage.

Actually, there are literally dozens (to maybe even hundreds) of alternatives for hosting static content for less money for more bandwidth.

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#206
post #9

Really nice, but the thing is... Dropbox has gone beyond just file sharing. One example: I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. I moved from Flickr to Picasa as it could cope with the directories full of photos and I didn't have to manually upload them and Google's storage space was cheaper. Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where…

FWIW this product fits my use case perfectly. I want to sync lots of data, but I don't want to pay for Dropbox because I really, really don't care if my stuff gets into the "cloud". I just want it across machines. Currently I use AeroFS, but this looks spiffy and might find a home on my hard drive.

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#207

> Those in the closed Alpha have already synced more than 200TB since we started the program,” BitTorrent announces. Umm, how do they know this if the sync is secure and only peer-to-peer?

Transfers being peer-to-peer doesn't prevent them from collecting statistics in the client.

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#208
post #9

Really nice, but the thing is... Dropbox has gone beyond just file sharing. One example: I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. I moved from Flickr to Picasa as it could cope with the directories full of photos and I didn't have to manually upload them and Google's storage space was cheaper. Then I ran out of space... over 100GB of photos, where…

> I used to use Flickr for photo sharing, but cameras got better, images got bigger, and I have a lot of photos. Why is this a problem with Flickr? I am generally shooting high res full frame, and post to Flickr. I have about a terabyte of images. There's no 100GB storage limit, just an annual flat fee. Family can download full resolution images for printing. My grandmother can have my Flickr Photo Stream as a screen…

> I also enjoy fantastic two way integration with photo management tools, with tagging syncing back.

Which photo management tools do you use? I currently have around 45k photos (~200GB) and Picasa is sometimes just too slow. I am planning to get a DSLR soon, so total size is going to be expanding rapidly. What kind of tools would you suggest? I am on Windows mainly, so Mac-only is not an option. Thanks!

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#209
So I just set this up on my home machine and a work machine..

I got caught out with the pre-defined host config because I didn't realise I needed to allow both tcp AND udp through the firewall, so my work machine was unable to access my privately shared folder on the home machine (tracker server/relay server/dht options all disabled)

Once that was sorted, I have a perfectly good replication system working amonst all my machines, just like dropbox, without the centralised control, this is awesome

Re: BitTorrent’s Secure Dropbox Alternative Goes Public

#210
post #21
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

A de facto standard, potential opensource clients, free, server-less, not tied to a specific company, and more.

> A de facto standard, > potential opensource clients, > not tied to a specific company, When the source is closed, and the protocol is closed + encrypted? I think you may be a little optimistic... (Though I do hope that either the source or the protocol get opened)

I think that's what made the original BitTorrent popular. The open protocol. They really need to do the same here if they want this to take off.
Post reply on HN