Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

venturebeat.com

21–30 of 87 posts

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#21
post #12

"mostly thanks to more than 5,800 one-star reviews." AKA, protest ratings. "This sucks in principle and I will never use it since Facebook is stupid."

Android doesn't let you rate things until after you've downloaded them, though. If that's truly the cause of these ratings, people are going through a lot of work to just say "facebook sucks".

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#22
post #4

I tried it out but I found it too suffocating -- Facebook, like Google, wants their "feed" to be your main IV-line of info-tainment but in practice the vapid updates of friends mixed in with poorly constructed advertisements isn't very engaging. If someone makes Facebook Home for aggregated RSS feeds, than they've invented mobile crack and I will never be able to put it down. So maybe don't do that. Also, Chat Heads…

vapid updates of friends

Don't friend people on Facebook who post garbage. Any social service (Facebook, Twitter, etc) is only as good as the effort you put into curating the experience.

Oh, and if you feel you must friend someone, you can just hide everything they post from your news feed.

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#23
post #4

I tried it out but I found it too suffocating -- Facebook, like Google, wants their "feed" to be your main IV-line of info-tainment but in practice the vapid updates of friends mixed in with poorly constructed advertisements isn't very engaging. If someone makes Facebook Home for aggregated RSS feeds, than they've invented mobile crack and I will never be able to put it down. So maybe don't do that. Also, Chat Heads…

vapid updates of friends Don't friend people on Facebook who post garbage. Any social service (Facebook, Twitter, etc) is only as good as the effort you put into curating the experience. Oh, and if you feel you must friend someone, you can just hide everything they post from your news feed.

Stop blaming the users for a bad product, especially when your suggestion goes against the core purpose of the product in question.

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#24
May be this is just be but I have never been comfortable with facebook's make-many-apps strategy. I've always used fb as a collective experience. I find the need to use different apps for different functionalities a pain in the ass, mostly because all facebook features are so intertwined.

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#25
post #7
post #4

I tried it out but I found it too suffocating -- Facebook, like Google, wants their "feed" to be your main IV-line of info-tainment but in practice the vapid updates of friends mixed in with poorly constructed advertisements isn't very engaging. If someone makes Facebook Home for aggregated RSS feeds, than they've invented mobile crack and I will never be able to put it down. So maybe don't do that. Also, Chat Heads…

Flipboard does quite a good job of grabbing content from multiple sources of your choice and displaying them in an attractive format. It's not a homescreen thing, but that's probably for the best. Do you really want non-urgent things shoved in your face constantly? Google Now has the most useful approach here, and I'm eager to see that developed even further. If you could populate it with selected RSS feeds, that wou…

The HTC One UI has an interesting feature for the default home screen that many compare to Flipboard called BlinkFeed. Choices of news feeds are limited and controlled, but it shows lots of promise in terms of attractive formatting and pulling in content from various social nets & news sources with tight integration with the social apps on your phone. (ala updating/replying/reposting something from home screen)

http://blog.htc.com/2013/03/htc-one-blinkfeed/

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#27
post #8

This is irrelevant. those intrusive apps are made with carrier integration in mind. You can't uninstall Facebook from any Samsung phone. And you won't uninstall Facebook home from the new s4 and updated s3 and notes. So, why care about user ratings?

> You can't uninstall Facebook from any Samsung phone

This is why I never stick with stock ROM (unless Nexus device), I have Cyanogenmod running on my Note II.

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#28
post #4

I tried it out but I found it too suffocating -- Facebook, like Google, wants their "feed" to be your main IV-line of info-tainment but in practice the vapid updates of friends mixed in with poorly constructed advertisements isn't very engaging. If someone makes Facebook Home for aggregated RSS feeds, than they've invented mobile crack and I will never be able to put it down. So maybe don't do that. Also, Chat Heads…

vapid updates of friends Don't friend people on Facebook who post garbage. Any social service (Facebook, Twitter, etc) is only as good as the effort you put into curating the experience. Oh, and if you feel you must friend someone, you can just hide everything they post from your news feed.

Has it occurred to you that there might be a use-case mismatch between treating a social network as a source of always-on, in-your-face infotainment and a communications vehicle with imperfect yet valued human beings you know and care about?

Or do you expect everyone you know to be excellent, always-interesting, content curators?

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#29
post #8

This is irrelevant. those intrusive apps are made with carrier integration in mind. You can't uninstall Facebook from any Samsung phone. And you won't uninstall Facebook home from the new s4 and updated s3 and notes. So, why care about user ratings?

You can't "uninstall" any app that the carrier forces on you, but you can disable it as of ICS or better. The app is both prevented from running and hidden from the app drawer.

In practice, the amount of storage you're denied from not being able to completely wipe these apps is miniscule.

Just one of the neat bits of control that the newer Android versions give you :)

Re: Facebook Home over a week later: only 500K installs with a two-star user rating

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

vapid updates of friends Don't friend people on Facebook who post garbage. Any social service (Facebook, Twitter, etc) is only as good as the effort you put into curating the experience. Oh, and if you feel you must friend someone, you can just hide everything they post from your news feed.

Stop blaming the users for a bad product, especially when your suggestion goes against the core purpose of the product in question.

Oh yeah and there's email, phone, and all kinds of other communication platforms. They are all bad products because there's so much spam, right?
Post reply on HN