Live data from Hacker News

New GitHub Logo

github.com

1–10 of 110 posts

Re: New GitHub Logo

#2
When the Octocat Mark is rendered at any size less than 75x75 pixels, it's pretty much impossible to tell that the "tail" of the cat is actually a tentacle.

That's unfortunate, because on https://github.com/logos the only recommended use for the mark is in social buttons, which are going to be relatively small.

Even at larger sizes, the tentacle just seems tacked on.

Re: New GitHub Logo

#5
It seems that GitHub wants a more "serious" look. I wonder why that is. Do managers dismiss GitHub for Enterprise as a possibility because it feels hackish/unprofessional?

Re: New GitHub Logo

#8
I'd really like to hear their thoughts around the capitalization of GitHub. Everyone who uses git interacts it with it in downcase. To see it upcased like that is unfamiliar.

Re: New GitHub Logo

#9
Given the old icon was just a lowercase g in various containers, I think this is a good step. The octocat is already recognizable, and although it's a little too detailed for small rendering, it's still relatively unique and distinct.

Nice work on this one. It may not be the perfect symbol, but it is uniquely and definitively github.

Post reply on HN