Live data from Hacker News

American airports do not rank in Top of the world

economist.com

31–40 of 60 posts

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#31
post #3

Other issues such as immigration process is a major cause of discontent at US aiirports when compared with other countries immigration workflow, particularly for non-locals.

Heathrow also has craptacular immigration and security handling and still managed to make the list. So there has to be more to it than that.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#34
Just a note, I have been several airports in the top 50 and I certainly do not agree with the rank. I don't know how they measured it, but I don't understand how Singapore can rank that high, I found it close to terrible while visiting. Furthermore, I would rank Copenhagen much higher than e.g. Zürich.

I don't use lounges, perhaps they represent a major part of the rank.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

SFO doesn't actually have TSA agents. Security is contracted through Covenant Aviation Security. See --> http://www.flysfo.com/web/page/atsfo/saf-sec/

Hmm, was it LAX? I'm reasonably certain SFO had scanners, but yeah, it might have been LAX.

I think they still have scanners - they're just not operated by the TSA - as in it's not a "government agency" running the operation.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#36

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Um, every other sign in that airport reads "death for drug traffickers". That's not any more pleasant than the TSA.

It's WAY more pleasant. I see the sign, it doesn't affect me, I am happy. I see the TSA, they go through my stuff, they treat me like a terrorist, I wonder if they're going to steal something, they enforce arbitrary rules at their discretion, they take up my time, the whole thing is very unpleasant.

I've been to both Changi and SFO - in SFO i walked more or less straight from the plane and out. Same experience when I departed. In Changi i was detained because of reasons they would not tell me. I was placed in a room with a lot of seats and was not allowed to make phone calls or ask any questions. At one point I stood up to walk to the desk and ask why I was detained and they immediately said I had to sit down and be quiet.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#37
post #10
post #8

That's odd, whenever I flew to SFO I had a great time. The TSA agents were more than happy to give me free massages, which you don't see anywhere else.

Think you're joking, but I came here to write - SFO is the best I can remember. Easy in and out, free wifi that actually worked and desks with power cords to use it from, regular and easy-to-understand shuttle bus system with helpful staff around, good access to cheap car hire and trains to town. Belongs miles ahead of Abu Dhabi. I bet Californians are a pickier bunch than the average airport visitor :)

I know most HN readers won't have too much experience with it, but the airport in Indianapolis is probably the best I've seen.

No traffic to the airport, in & out of security in 5 minutes (longest I've waited is 10 minutes), free wifi AND a TSA agent smiled at me. It's like another world.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Changi airport is exactly what airports should be like. It's a nice place to be instead of a horrible warehouse with lots of signs warning you that you're an accidental bottle of water away from being labelled a terrorist.

Um, every other sign in that airport reads "death for drug traffickers". That's not any more pleasant than the TSA.

Nonsense, I flew out of Changi last week and can't recall a single sign warning about the death penalty for drug trafficking.

The warning is on the customs form that you fill in when you fly into Singapore, as you'd expect. But comparing it to the TSA is facile as they're unavoidable if you're flying in the US.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#39

Just a note, I have been several airports in the top 50 and I certainly do not agree with the rank. I don't know how they measured it, but I don't understand how Singapore can rank that high, I found it close to terrible while visiting. Furthermore, I would rank Copenhagen much higher than e.g. Zürich. I don't use lounges, perhaps they represent a major part of the rank.

Singapore airport is great. Delicious Laksa, a butterfly enclosure, spacious with good shopping. Not sure which airport you went to.

Re: American airports do not rank in Top of the world

#40
One thing that stood out to me is Lima airport being top 30. That airport unless it was completely overhauled in the last 2 years was a huge POS. I say that because half the flights are hours delayed every time I have flown there, the place was filthy each time I visited, and felt like a regional airport not a world class one.
Post reply on HN