Live data from Hacker News

Facebook Home

facebook.com

81–90 of 227 posts

Re: Facebook Home

#81
post #69

Funny how the video contains only women... like if facebook was the only site most women would go on :)

I'm not quite sure what you're getting at but it's weird to me too. You never know what lead to that decision (target markets, promotional video production issues, or maybe they just wanted to play off the "girl at home on the phone with friends" archetype) but it is odd.

Re: Facebook Home

#82
post #16

I take issue with the problem statement: "today, phones are built around tasks and apps. To see what's happening with your friends, you pull out your phone and navigate through a series of separate apps." Firstly, the value to me in owning a smartphone and paying the charges associated with it is ultimately task orientated - from running my business, to getting driving directions, to wanting to play a specific genre…

I agree with the basic core of what they're saying- apps are silos, especially on iOS. If they allow third parties to also push content to Facebook Home (and they've been friendly to third parties for a long time) the idea could yet be sound.

Re: Facebook Home

#84

I think the biggest thing for me is that my smartphone has always been a "private" thing for me, a place where I can choose to interact with people, or spend hours playing Angry Birds. With this phone, I'm forced into an environment where I feel like I need to be social all the time, and I feel that might wear on a lot of people.

I don't install non-work IM programs on my desktops anymore because I found that an 'online' status typically denoted to people that I'm available to talk. It got to a point where my wife was even pinging me too often. Then I just put it on unavailable/offline all the time and then what's the point of having it in the first place?

I think the younger generation doesn't have an expectation of non-invasiveness yet. They just aren't doing anything important enough to be bothered when interrupted. I think that changes when you get a little older.

Re: Facebook Home

#85
post #59

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These worries are true for anything you install on Android. This is just another app, just presente differently.

Consider the source. FB has much higher and invasive corporate and government connections who would love to use that data than the SuperGronk "just another app" game company does.

Why differentiate? I see FB as a phishing exercise, a specific app may be more like spearphishing.

Re: Facebook Home

#86
This looks pretty neat. I might end up installing it just to avoid using the abomination that is the official Facebook for Android app.

Re: Facebook Home

#87
post #22

The greatest benefit of a facebook phone to me has nothing to do with photos, status updates, etc (although I am likely in the minority). Facebook, to me, has become an address book of all of my friends, with contact information that updates itself when it changes. If facebook replaced my address book with my facebook friends list, and texting and calling to them "just worked", hopefully using facebook-to-facebook ov…

I've heard others say something similar in regards to their contacts. What do you do when you are not friends with someone? Just curious as I don't use Facebook often.

Re: Facebook Home

#88
What a landing page. Almost makes me want to start using Facebook again. Now, this is the step before Facebook forks android, and builds their own apps store. And then they build their own signature phone, then a tablet, and so on...

Re: Facebook Home

#90
post #42

I'm skeptical that some of what winds up on the FB home screen won't include some form of advertising.

No need to be skeptical, Facebook has already said they will put advertising on your home screen (it was a question from the press.)
Post reply on HN