Live data from Hacker News

The Meme Hustler - Tim O’Reilly’s crazy talk

thebaffler.com

81–84 of 84 posts

Re: The Meme Hustler - Tim O’Reilly’s crazy talk

#81
post #76
post #30

Evgeny Morozov is just a poor man's Malcolm Gladwell, and one focused solely on being contrarian to anything future-thinking, which makes him a darling for old media. Here's a recent interview with him from Gawker: http://gawker.com/5990608/a-discussion-with-evgeny-morozov-s... Here's he talks about something he thinks he read on Hacker News: http://gawker.com/5990608/?post=58282779 > I don't think we should ban them…

Are you saying that Morozov should have been talking about ridiculing Libertarians instead of ridiculing tech blogs when he brought up that assertion? Perhaps that seems like a major error to you? I don't think it would to him.

Morozov didn't disappoint, the last 8,000 words were devoted to ridiculing Libertarians.

Re: The Meme Hustler - Tim O’Reilly’s crazy talk

#82
I'm disappointed in Hacker News. The top comments seem to be about people lacking the patience to read the article and then criticising the article for being too long!

Please either spend real time reading the article and thinking about it and then comment, or don't comment at all.

Re: The Meme Hustler - Tim O’Reilly’s crazy talk

#83

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Hey, what a surprise - the top comment on a HN post comes from a reader who dismisses the post outright despite failing to actually read it in its entirety.

Your ad hominem attack against me is not appreciated, nor is your attempt to treat me as a category and stereotype rather than a real person behind a keyboard. Like others here, I make it a general rule to read everything, and even consulting other sources, before commenting. Like others here also, I had not the time nor the inclination to go through the entirety of a 16,000 word behemoth of writing when the first 8,…

What sanctimonious rubbish. The top comment added nothing to the debate, and failed to engage with anything the article said.

And now you dress that comment up as reasoned and adding value. Wow.

Re: The Meme Hustler - Tim O’Reilly’s crazy talk

#84
So far no commenter has mentioned that this piece appeared in The Baffler, where Aaron Swartz was a contributing editor.

The announcement of Swartz joining The Baffler was previously linked here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3298445

While Morozov's essay to some may appear to be coming out of left field, it's actually appearing in a venue that takes ethical concerns in relation to technological innovation quite seriously as evidenced by whom it associates with.

Post reply on HN