Live data from Hacker News

A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

littlebrown.co.uk

31–40 of 363 posts

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#31
post #29

He shouldn't just accept this. There has to be something to be tried. With his notoriety, the option to try some experimental new treatment should at least be considered.

I've seen my grand mother die from gallbladder cancer. Weeks leading to her death she was miserable, she didn't have a minute of rest. Since then I understand why some people choose to end it early instead of prolonging the suffering...

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#32
FWIW, I've ordered the first three novels of the Culture series. I didn't know of Iain Banks until today and his terrible news.

I just wish he'll live the most playful last months of his life with his soon-to-be wife. We cannot wish for anything less.

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#33
post #29

He shouldn't just accept this. There has to be something to be tried. With his notoriety, the option to try some experimental new treatment should at least be considered.

Nonsense.

He knows it's terminal (it's spread all over the place), and if he chooses to live the rest of his life on his own terms and not enduring the significant side effects of chemo, then it's his choice and good luck to him.

My grandmother refused chemo (cancer in bowel, liver, lymph nodes) and I think she made the right choice.

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#34

Terrible news. If you're not familiar with Iain's work you owe it to yourself to drop everything and start reading the Culture series[1] right now. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_series

I absolutely love the Culture series. Although it doesn't delve into the Culture universe proper, Use of Weapons is one of the best books I've read. Would highly recommend checking out this book. The two narrative flows and the conclusion at the end, wow, just wow.

Definitely very sad news.

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#35

He's a titan of British literature, I've loved his work for a number of years. What a legacy to leave behind.

As an English Brit I'd love to claim him for our own but, to be honest, I think "Scottish literature" is the only appropriate description. This is awful news. I've not been a big fan of his later SF works. But Feersum Endjinn and Espedair St are tremendous and who knows, maybe the later works will grown on me. I hope he lives to see his latest book on the shelves. (Edit: Not that I'm claiming he's not a Titan)

I'll agree with that actually, he's in favour of an independent Scotland as his dream of a socialist Britain is unlikely (from a Guardian article he wrote a while back).

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#36
Another person that might be cryopreserved [1], but probably won't be, much like the 150,000 who passed in the last day or so [2]. Many sorts of terminal case can actually lead to better quality cryopreservation under present legal restrictions [3], in comparison to the drawn out and uncertain end of aging, precisely because they are more rapid and certain in time.

(Or might be plastinated [4] in the alternate history thread in which people actually got up and started to do something about death in the late 1930s [5], when the chemical industry started to be up to the task of building a mass plastination concern).

If you've made no preparations but still have $200,000 or so sitting around, then the certainty of oblivion is still your choice, even at the last minute. (Most people who are cryopreserved fund it through life insurance taken out decades earlier). No judgement on that choice is offered, as the right to vanish is a good right, just judgement on the fact that while other options do exist, they might be far more available for everyone and better thought of were the world just a little bit different.

[1] http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2002/11/cryonics.php

[2] http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2002/12/death-is-an-outra...

[3] http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/02/to-die-in-order-t...

[4] http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2009/04/plastinate-everyo...

[5] http://www.fightaging.org/archives/2011/05/when-did-we-becom...

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#37
post #32

FWIW, I've ordered the first three novels of the Culture series. I didn't know of Iain Banks until today and his terrible news. I just wish he'll live the most playful last months of his life with his soon-to-be wife. We cannot wish for anything less.

Oh to be reading them again for the first time. I envy you.

This is a lamentable loss indeed. It really grieves me that my shelf of Culture novels will likely never grow again.

Fuck this fucking disease. It really makes me angry. The lives cut short, all those possibilities lost. We need to fix this bug and soon.

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#39
post #29

He shouldn't just accept this. There has to be something to be tried. With his notoriety, the option to try some experimental new treatment should at least be considered.

He doesn't have a chance of lasting more than a few months, most of which will be painful and with rapidly decreasing functioning. With the type and severity of his cancer, an experimental new treatment will simply ensure that his last days are more painful than they need be.

Re: A Personal Statement from Iain Banks

#40
It was a great surprise for me to see him at the book signing event a couple of months ago in Bristol. Not a deep and mysterious person I imagined him to be after reading the books - just a great, happy guy who shared some thoughts about his imagination. He could really make the whole room laugh.
Post reply on HN