Live data from Hacker News

Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

online.wsj.com

1–10 of 91 posts

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#2
In contrast, in the U.S., "people have to even clean their own toilets,"

You know, I could easily afford to have someone clean my toilet. In fact, our receptionist offered to be my housekeeper, at good terms. But...I don't know...I just don't want 3rd parties involved in the matter. I guess it's my lower-middle class heritage thing.

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#3
I find it shocking that some Indian men have such attitudes, despite having spent time in places like the US.

Given the difficulty in finding matches for Indians abroad, some matchmakers are now charging them more. Mr. Dave of Klassic Match charges a minimum fee of $100, versus $50 for candidates living in India. He charges more for specific requirements. For instance, he says some overseas Indians want a bride who is smart, fluent in English, and "simultaneously, docile in the house." He says such women are now harder to find, so he bumps up his fees for some searches.

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#4

I find it shocking that some Indian men have such attitudes, despite having spent time in places like the US. Given the difficulty in finding matches for Indians abroad, some matchmakers are now charging them more. Mr. Dave of Klassic Match charges a minimum fee of $100, versus $50 for candidates living in India. He charges more for specific requirements. For instance, he says some overseas Indians want a bride who i…

Maybe it is because they have spent time in the US that they want such women?

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#5
India has some weird cultural aspects that I do not find appealing personally.

I had an Indian friend on a H1-B who talked a lot about getting a wife that cooked and cleaned and stuff and I always asked him, "Why not just hire a maid? Probably be cheaper." He could never come up with a good response.

I guess these attitudes come from being raised in a culture where it's the norm. I've got another few friends who are first generation and they never talked about anything like that at all. Makes me wonder what fundamental change in Indian society will disrupt those attitudes; will a simple increase in per capita income and an equalization of the labor pool do it, or is it at a more ingrained level?

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#6

I find it shocking that some Indian men have such attitudes, despite having spent time in places like the US. Given the difficulty in finding matches for Indians abroad, some matchmakers are now charging them more. Mr. Dave of Klassic Match charges a minimum fee of $100, versus $50 for candidates living in India. He charges more for specific requirements. For instance, he says some overseas Indians want a bride who i…

Another explanation could be that the Indians in the US are mostly engineers, who skew towards being introverted. I'm guessing wildly here, but my point is that it could be more than cultural factors at play.

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#7
post #4

I find it shocking that some Indian men have such attitudes, despite having spent time in places like the US. Given the difficulty in finding matches for Indians abroad, some matchmakers are now charging them more. Mr. Dave of Klassic Match charges a minimum fee of $100, versus $50 for candidates living in India. He charges more for specific requirements. For instance, he says some overseas Indians want a bride who i…

Maybe it is because they have spent time in the US that they want such women?

I dont know about that. Why is that?

I would be willing to give the benefit of the doubt to somebody who has lived in a conservative, patriarchal, rural/small-town middle class environment in India.

If you are an Indian male in the US as described in the article, chances are you come from an urban background, went to college, and have had ample opportunity to be exposed to more liberal attitudes. In that case, this sort of expectation is downright shameful and disgusting.

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#8

In contrast, in the U.S., "people have to even clean their own toilets," You know, I could easily afford to have someone clean my toilet. In fact, our receptionist offered to be my housekeeper, at good terms. But...I don't know...I just don't want 3rd parties involved in the matter. I guess it's my lower-middle class heritage thing.

Partially a cultural thing, too. Americans don't do "servants", for certain values of "servant".

Similarly, if you come to Japan and try to explain babysitting, you get looks of total horror.

"Yes, I think its perfectly normal to talk to a mother I know, get the name of a 13 year old girl who lives in the neighborhood, pay her $20 so that I can have an evening out with my wife, and entrust my home and infant child to her within 5 minutes of meeting her. You find this odd?"

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#9
post #6

I find it shocking that some Indian men have such attitudes, despite having spent time in places like the US. Given the difficulty in finding matches for Indians abroad, some matchmakers are now charging them more. Mr. Dave of Klassic Match charges a minimum fee of $100, versus $50 for candidates living in India. He charges more for specific requirements. For instance, he says some overseas Indians want a bride who i…

Another explanation could be that the Indians in the US are mostly engineers, who skew towards being introverted. I'm guessing wildly here, but my point is that it could be more than cultural factors at play.

[deleted]

Re: Ineligible Bachelors: Indian Men Living in U.S. Strike Out

#10

India has some weird cultural aspects that I do not find appealing personally. I had an Indian friend on a H1-B who talked a lot about getting a wife that cooked and cleaned and stuff and I always asked him, "Why not just hire a maid? Probably be cheaper." He could never come up with a good response. I guess these attitudes come from being raised in a culture where it's the norm. I've got another few friends who are…

Most people don't want to have kids with their maid. Indians in this scenario prefer to marry people at the same socioeconomic level
Post reply on HN