Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

doineedavisafor.com

141–150 of 164 posts

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#141
Here's why I don't understand the point of a site like this.

I don't know anything about the site. I don't know if it's accurate. I don't know if it's maintained. I can't trust the information on it, so if I get an answer from it, in order to verify it I'll have to do whatever work I would have done if the site didn't exist. I've gained nothing.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#142

Here's why I don't understand the point of a site like this. I don't know anything about the site. I don't know if it's accurate. I don't know if it's maintained. I can't trust the information on it, so if I get an answer from it, in order to verify it I'll have to do whatever work I would have done if the site didn't exist. I've gained nothing.

EDIT: As mietek points out below, the site does provide precisely this information.

I guess that every answer that the site gives could link back to an authoritative source (such as a site run by the government of the destination country), in order to give you an opportunity to verify that the information is correct.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#143

Here's why I don't understand the point of a site like this. I don't know anything about the site. I don't know if it's accurate. I don't know if it's maintained. I can't trust the information on it, so if I get an answer from it, in order to verify it I'll have to do whatever work I would have done if the site didn't exist. I've gained nothing.

EDIT: As mietek points out below, the site does provide precisely this information. I guess that every answer that the site gives could link back to an authoritative source (such as a site run by the government of the destination country), in order to give you an opportunity to verify that the information is correct.

Isn't this exactly what the site does? If you're snarking on the parent poster, then your subtlety went over my head.

Example: http://www.doineedavisafor.com/visa/polish-citizen/travellin...

"Source: http://ec.europa.eu/justice/citizen/move-live/index_en.htm

Last checked: 4 March, 2013"

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One of my canadian friends likes to raise her hand at big meetings when someone asks if there are any americans there.

And if your friend had to choose one and only one descriptor between "Canadian" or "American", what would they say?

No, she just finds it fun that the US has decided to call themselves by the common name of two continents.

I will propose that Norway call itself the United States of Europe and we start calling ourself europeans and poke fun at the EU.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All my friends from Canada and South America find this hilarious. But then South Korea simply calls itself Korea and ignores the north.

So these are people who live outside of the United States that describe their nationality as "American"? Do any of them live in countries that actually have "America" in the name?

Btw. I'm european, even though I don't live in a country that's even part of the EU (we are part of both the EEA and Schengen area, though)...Norway FTW.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#146
post #47

I don't understand the presentation. Allow the user to choose nationality from a drop down box, then show a world map colored various ways: - green no visa - blue for easy to obtain visas - red for difficult to obtain visas On a side note, it should probably be "United States citizen" and not "US". Also, US -> China is a very common route that requires a visiting / mailing your passport to a Chinese embassy to obtain…

Regarding the US to China route, this is more complicated than it would seem. While getting a visa is probably the easiest solution, there are some situations where it is not required. An example being that you can enter visa-free into Shanghai for 48 hours if you're in transit through the airport.

There are some other odd visa-on-arrival schemes available for places like Shenzhen if you're arriving via Hong Kong (although I think this isn't available to US citizens, only to Australians, and a few other nationalities). I wouldn't be surprised if this is true of some of the other Special Economic Zones as well (e.g. Hainan island). It can be really hard to find this information though, even through official channels.

So this kind of confusion is what the author is up against when collecting data.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#147

Here's why I don't understand the point of a site like this. I don't know anything about the site. I don't know if it's accurate. I don't know if it's maintained. I can't trust the information on it, so if I get an answer from it, in order to verify it I'll have to do whatever work I would have done if the site didn't exist. I've gained nothing.

Did you actually try it? It gives you a direct link to the relevant document, so you don't have to trust the site and you don't have to go digging.

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#148
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Come on. It's a great little service whether there is a map or not. Drop downs with autocomplete work well for choosing countries. I especially like that there are links to primary sources and that the service is careful when it doesn't know: "Sorry, we've no information available. We're careful to only use accurate, first-hand information, but have been unable to confirm the visa requirements for Andorran citizens t…

I suppose that OP wanted feedback. Suggestions for improvements aren't criticism, they're free consulting.

"I don't understand the presentation" as a reaction to two massive dropdowns qualifies as consulting these days?

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#149
Nice side project!

A dual citizenship feature might be a nice touch - for instance travelling to Brazil is easier on a European passport than an Australian. So it would be great to know what to use when.

One bug report: On the one page - Australian citizens require a visa to visit Canada. Australian citizens do not require a visa to visit Canada.

http://www.doineedavisafor.com/visa/australian-citizen/trave...

Re: Show HN: My side project – Do I need a visa for...?

#150
post #89
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Usually it's pretty easy to get a Visa on arrival at most African countries, yet when I tried to add that, I was asked to log in through either Google or Facebook (I like neither). When I saw that it required my permission to use some data on my Google account even when I'm not using the site, I declined and then got a typical Rails error page.

The permission to use some data is the minimum permission requested (Email address). The intent here is to use OAuth to allow easy logins, not harvest data. BTW, The entire site is open-source at http://www.github.com/udit99/visamapper , so not only can you a) Verify that there is no foul play, but b) send pull requests with alternative login methods.

To verify that there's no foul play, there would also need to be a way to check that the code on github is what is actually running on the site...
Post reply on HN