Live data from Hacker News

Chess CAPTCHA

en.lichess.org

21–30 of 171 posts

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#22
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It also keeps out beginners. Depending on the forum (I'm not familiar with lichess) that might be a drawback or a bonus.

The captcha seems very easy (I am not a chess player)- I tried three times and always got a board to solve in one move, so I doubt anyone that knows the rules of chess is going to be excluded. That's probably not a problem for this forum :)

It is easy. But it still filters out some kind of people you may not want on a chess forum :)

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#24
post #9

What's with the "Ping" at the bottom of the page. Why would someone do that?

A quick google gives this; apparently from the creator. "I[t] tells how fast your computer talks with lichess server. It measures the time a message needs to make the round trip from your browser to lichess, then from lichess to your browser. I'm interrested in knowing what your ping is, depending on the country/city where you live. I live in Le Mans, France, and my ping is around 30-40ms. What about you?" {source} h…

If you play speed chess, latency might become a significant problem (depending on your skills/speed).

edit: I wanted to comment on the parent comment. Sorry.

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#25
post #21

Can brute force answer from the server quicky: http://en.lichess.org/captcha/0nbdeigw?solution=a1+a2 returns either 1 or 0. The total complexity of this to brute force is 768 possible moves. Most of us here could write a bot to spam their site with less than 30 minutes of time and effort.

Philistine! At least plug it into a chess AI and do it properly.

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#26
This is a very creative CAPTCHA. However, computers are rather good at playing chess, so a chess problem is probably the least thing you want to use to distinguish between humans and computers (unless your aims is to keep stupid humans out). Other possibilities: guess fruits (http://www.eurekalert.org/pub_releases/2013-03/ip-std030613....), human emotions, animals etc.

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#27
post #5

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It also keeps out beginners. Depending on the forum (I'm not familiar with lichess) that might be a drawback or a bonus.

The captcha seems very easy (I am not a chess player)- I tried three times and always got a board to solve in one move, so I doubt anyone that knows the rules of chess is going to be excluded. That's probably not a problem for this forum :)

Agreed. I had never played chess in my life, but with the help of Wikipedia [1], I figured out which piece to move where.

(I enjoy this mini chess, it's like a low tech version of Bejeweled. I don't have the patience for full fledged chess games, but just finding the last move is fun.)

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess#Movement

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#28
post #21

Can brute force answer from the server quicky: http://en.lichess.org/captcha/0nbdeigw?solution=a1+a2 returns either 1 or 0. The total complexity of this to brute force is 768 possible moves. Most of us here could write a bot to spam their site with less than 30 minutes of time and effort.

But serious spammers would prefer to spend this time writing a bot capable of spamming all forums based on some widely used engine.

Cracking this captcha won't give you access to any significant audience.

Re: Chess CAPTCHA

#30
post #21

Can brute force answer from the server quicky: http://en.lichess.org/captcha/0nbdeigw?solution=a1+a2 returns either 1 or 0. The total complexity of this to brute force is 768 possible moves. Most of us here could write a bot to spam their site with less than 30 minutes of time and effort.

Or use Rybka which can do it much quicker.
Post reply on HN