Live data from Hacker News

Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies

yro.slashdot.org

141–144 of 144 posts

Re: Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies

#141
post #70
post #2

Excellent. Now we need to block third party javascript and then we have a chance at a more secure web. After all, any third party javascript could be done by an underwater call between the server and the provider of the service.

There is plenty of third party javascript that is not at all predatory. Pretty much all analytics services, Olark and other similar customer outreach services, A/B testing suites. There is far more of a push to create new more secure avenues for third party js (namely cors and websockets) to exist than there are efforts to eliminate it. I'm curious how this change will effect services like optimizely that rely on thi…

We would go back to hosting our own stuff.

Big deal.

Re: Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies

#142
post #26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except Google Analytics doesn't use third party cookies so it's a moot point. https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection...

Does this mean that GA can't track users across websites?

Google provides a way to do it: https://developers.google.com/analytics/devguides/collection...

Re: Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies

#143
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is a general rule of thumb that a person has to look at/interact with/be cognitively aware of an ad at least 7 times before any action can be taken. Showing ads across sites is just one more way to do that. In fact I would rather have relevant ads show up than irrelevant ads. I will admit that many companies out there do overdo their retargeting campaign though. That's what the company does that is mistaken, no…

Sorry, retargeting ? I assume this is why I get ads for stuff I just bought on wildly different sites - the advertising network server asks for my cookie before serving the ad and so can identify me? Yeah that's annoying. I will install adblock one day, but in defence of chewxy I just tend to avoid sites with that crap on them anyway.

If you are logged into gmail (and the site uses adwords), wont this still happen, even with 3rd party cookies disabled?

Re: Firefox Will Soon Block Third-Party Cookies

#144
post #99

Earlier quoted context omitted.

why do you consider it evil? it seems like a great way to reach back out to someone who was potentially interested in your service. if all retargeting is doing is showing you ads from a website you already visited. How is that evil? Are babies dead because of it? Or perhaps do you remember that you like that website and eventually signup because you got the extra reminder... that is just called advertising and it's w…

Did they tell you they were interested? Hand you a business card? No, you're stalking them. That's why it's bad. *impersonal you

If walked into my office to browse or came into my retail store to browse I think you are it might be interested - but really this is the Internet so it's neither a stalker or an brick and mortor store... You can choose to block third party cookies - If we make them off by default you lose that choice
Post reply on HN