Live data from Hacker News

I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

makeuseof.com

51–60 of 115 posts

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#51

I find this wildly at odds with the experience of my friends. Granted they are early adopter type folk but they have taken to tablets extremely intently. They use them for gaming, and browsing, and other miscellaneous activities. Just because they are not great at everything doesn't mean they can't be incredibly useful tools.

The author talked about "productive use" - you listed gaming and browsing. In many circles those don't rank as productivity. There's a fine difference between "great"/"cool" and "being productive".

Are we being a bit condescending by insinuating that points earned or facebook walls commented on, is not productive? I'm sure you cure cancer with every 5th keystroke of your best selling novels and crush awesome ruby code for breakfast.

You're espousing a pretty narrow view of what a computing device can be used for in a way that produces some value for its user.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#52
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The author talked about "productive use" - you listed gaming and browsing. In many circles those don't rank as productivity. There's a fine difference between "great"/"cool" and "being productive".

Are we being a bit condescending by insinuating that points earned or facebook walls commented on, is not productive? I'm sure you cure cancer with every 5th keystroke of your best selling novels and crush awesome ruby code for breakfast. You're espousing a pretty narrow view of what a computing device can be used for in a way that produces some value for its user.

You are allowed to find a device useful (i.e. gain value out of it) without being productive on it. That is why e-Readers sell a lot - they are useful. We're arguing about productive use cases here and that in my mind does not include commenting on facebook walls. If that is a narrow viewpoint then that's fine with me.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#53
I think productivity is reflected in the software we use, not the device.

I've long maintained that there was no more productive time or software or device in my life than a Palm os device with Datebk6. In contrast, it was made to be productive, not novel, or distracting. Today's phones have all this horsepower, but to what outcome?

It's a fair reflection that right now we're working our way learning through the novelty and distraction app economy.

The masses don't know what else to do with tech (be productive?) because their interaction with tech (tv, radio, web) has always been about finding that next hit of novelty or distraction.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#54
I found the iPad to be a better media consumption device than my laptop. Which means that I rarely spend my non-productive time on the laptop. Which in turn creates a higher spatial divide between work and entertainment, creating designated places for each. That alone makes me less likely to procrastinate and more productive.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#56
under the assumption that something like "reading a book" is considered productive

1) surfing the web from my couch

2) some games like plants vs. zombies are sublime on a tablet, much better than on a pc imho

3) pdfs read much better than on a pc or a kindle

4) comic books (cbz and cbr files) on a ~10" tablet are almost as good as the real thing

5) when docked, my tablet makes a fantastic picture frame showing the photos in my google+ account

6) there's some music production software that are really quite good, I like Caustic myself, there's similar for iOS.

7) lots and lots and lots of pretty decent painting apps

8) I use it to see notifications, task, etc. things that I've entered from my PC into some "cloud" service. calendars, trello tasks, etc. Just bringing my tablet into a meeting with trello pulled up on it makes it seem like a have a super human memory and is far less intrusive than a laptop

9) use it as a third monitor, there's some great wifi streaming apps that tell your OS to use it as another monitor. Sure it's a bit slow, but if I stash my email program over there, or a shell that's tailing a log or something, it's perfectly adequate

10) better yet, just put a shell app on there direct and ssh into the server and tail the app that way, keeping tabs on a long running startup process while I'm in the bathroom has never been easier

11) remote to my PC running VLC...it's awesome for this, I can seek fast forward and rewind, control volume, pause play, whatever...custom home touch panel remotes don't hold a candle to this

things I don't do

try to type non-trivial amounts of text quickly without a keyboard, which is where most of the examples from this post are about, which is weird since he's using a transformer prime...who's entire point is the keyboard dock

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#57
Strangely, I heard a very similar rant from my Dad when he swore up and down he had no use for a cell phone. He left it turned off and in the glove box of his car initially because the only use for it he could imagine was if he was on the road somewhere and couldn't find a pay phone.

When folks ask me "What is a Tablet good for?" I tell them its a TV you can carry around. Oh and you can read books and news papers on it. Oh and you can look at pictures you've taken on it. Oh and you can video chat with someone on it. Oh and it will give you directions on how to get some where.

I have a keyboard case for those times when I need to use an ssh client to do something, I sometimes compose comments to HN on the train, but I don't really do any development on the thing.

But I also know that my finding a place for it in my work flow is completely orthogonal to my Dad doing the same. (although he immediately got an retina ipad when they came out to preview pictures he takes, its a much better preview than the display on his DSLR)

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#58
post #51

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The author talked about "productive use" - you listed gaming and browsing. In many circles those don't rank as productivity. There's a fine difference between "great"/"cool" and "being productive".

Are we being a bit condescending by insinuating that points earned or facebook walls commented on, is not productive? I'm sure you cure cancer with every 5th keystroke of your best selling novels and crush awesome ruby code for breakfast. You're espousing a pretty narrow view of what a computing device can be used for in a way that produces some value for its user.

"Productive" is used in its more literal definition here: producing, m/aking, creating. It doesn't have to be shakespeare or picasso to still be a creative work.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#59

Tablet is primarily a media consumption device. So - reading/learning. That can be productive. I also reply to emails and schedule calendar events from it. As soon as I need to edit documents, manage servers, or write code - I move to a laptop or desktop, it's just more comfortable. P.S. wrote this on my iPad

I don't think reading/learning are productive use cases. Productivity, IMHO, means you create/produce something that is tangentially different (regardless of how small it is) than what existed before an activity. In the minds of most people, creating new knowledge or acquiring new information does not conform to the above definition. You could argue though that iPads and other tablets _help_ you stay productive on a…

When I read, I come up with ideas. Key is to stay off News, FB.

Re: I Can't Find a Single Productive Use For My Tablet

#60
Tablets make a great 2nd (or 3rd) screen to supplement your computer workstation. You can keep reference material open on the tablet, which is a good read-only device. The one missing link is cut-and-paste from tablet to PC, and there are apps for that.

With browser sync, you can look something up on the main screen, then carry the tablet to the lunchroom (or toilet) to read it.

Tablets are fantastic for children. If you have kids, you may find that they take to it like a fish to water. You may want to steer them toward educational nature videos and math games, rather than mind-numbing running games like Temple Run, just to justify all that time they could have spent reading a book or playing ball outdoors.

Tablets are handy for reading or watching shows in the dark. My wife and I are watching Downton Abbey in bed. It's not ideal--I wish I had a robot arm thingie to hold the tablet rather than having it balanced on my chest, digging a ditch into my skin. But it's good enough; easy to pause and go back to catch what they said (we're not British and the dialects are sometimes tough to follow).

Basically, tablets are quite useful, and there's about 100 million users just in the U.S., so they must be doing something right! What's more, I suspect we've only scratched the surface of what these gadgets can do.

Post reply on HN