Live data from Hacker News

VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

vascheduling.challenge.gov

1–10 of 42 posts

Re: VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

#5
post #4

It's not just a scheduling, there are a bunch of legacy systems you have to integrate with. And of course it's health data, so there are more requirements. Anyone want to burn three months on an unpaid spec? :)

Man, contests like this seem like a bad idea for everyone involved. Solicit bids, take 2 million dollars and get a prototype/demonstration of capability from your top 4-8 options. Review the submitted work and communication each contractor provided, select the one that you feel the most comfortable with and just pay them to make the damn thing.

Re: VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

#6
post #4

It's not just a scheduling, there are a bunch of legacy systems you have to integrate with. And of course it's health data, so there are more requirements. Anyone want to burn three months on an unpaid spec? :)

A couple of points from the OP:

* The replacement product will, as a part of the overall VistA EHR, deliver privacy, security, data integrity, patient accessibility, interoperability and other services required by federal law, regulations and VA policy. Many of these services are delivered by other components of VistA.

* VA intends to replace the current MSP with a scheduling product[1] which is a standards-based, modular, extensible and scalable, certified as compliant and fully interoperable with the production version of VistA now held by the Open Source Electronic Health Record Agent (OSEHRA), http://www.osehra.org/.

So the app won't have to replace everything...and it may get away with interfacing with some of the more easily interoperable aspects of the system. The main goal behind the contest is "To encourage development of systems that help Veterans schedule appointments to receive care from the Veterans Health Administration and to reduce risks in the future procurement and deployment of those systems"...which is vague enough to include a range of ancillary software services. And I doubt the federal contractors who likely receive much bigger amounts to maintain legacy systems would want the VA to install a system that makes them obsolete.

And on a more subjective note, large sums of money have been awarded to other government ChallengePost winner that were essentially proofs of concept and are barely functional today, if ever heavily used.

Re: VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

#7
This is badly needed. Appointments can take longer than two weeks. For example, if a veteran has PTSD and cannot get immediate care when they're experiencing an anxiety attack that lasts for more than a day, it can result in extreme consequences such as suicide.

Re: VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

#8

$3million? They should go with http://www.makeplans.net instead: starting at $10/month :)

I think the point of the contest is to spur innovation and fresh ideas in a system that's clearly lacking in that department, not just to build a simple "scheduling app"

Re: VA Medical Appointment Scheduling Contest – $9M in prizes

#10

"If an individual, an entrant must be a citizen of or permanent resident of the United States". You have already lost 96% of contestants who could have contributed.

Not necessarily. How hard would it be to find an American person to collaborate with who can represent the group?
Post reply on HN