Live data from Hacker News

Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

johannakoll.posterous.com

81–90 of 257 posts

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#81
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> For those who think it doesn't matter, and that there is no sexism and that women aren't be discriminated against due to the pure fact of their gender, be aware that there have been double blinded scientific studies that show that if you change the name of a CV/resume to a female name when applying for science jobs, they don't get as much/as good offers. Then maybe try to fix that instead of complaining about bikin…

> Would anyone raise even an eyebrow if a woman sliped a sexy male model photo in a slide? Uh, yes? Why would anyone ever do that?

As a punchline to a joke about some software being superficially attractive, e.g.

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#82
post #7

People laugh when they hear a "sexist" joke because it's funny. Maybe gender related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

Sure, there should be room for jokes of all kinds: at a standup comedy show, in private among friends and family, etc.

We "all" laugh at jokes that are funny until we hear one that "isn't so funny" because it targets something painful in us.

For example, I'm pretty damn tired of all jokes about Balkans, ex-Yugoslavia, Serbia, etc. A lot of them are even true, but after several wars and a bombing campaign from NATO and leaving the country because I feel deserve a future denied to me by choices of previous generations, let's just say that I can't appreciate that particular humor anymore.

Now, imagine being a woman. Imagine growing up with TV cartoons grooming you to become a princess, a fashion model or, if you failed at that, a housewife. Imagine getting only a certain kind of gifts for birthday, in certain colors. Imagine people paying more attention to your breasts than what you're saying to them. And then imagine hearing sexist jokes since you were a kid. Would you really find a sexist joke funny at a conference?

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#83
>A talk at a conference showing girls in bikinis. An API presentation from a sponsor featuring ladies in bras. A demo at a hack day with a slide of women in underwear. A business model canvas workshop using a strip club as an example to illustrate the tool. These are just a few examples of casual sexism I've experience at (tech) events.

Where does sexy end and sexism begin? I too am against sexism (who isn't?), but most Americans appear to find women in limited amounts of clothing sexy; take a look at most women's magazines in the grocery store next time you're there (or, better yet, look through a bunch of Cosmos at some point: someone suggested I do it, and I found the experience highly educational). Sexism in tech and the workplace are real problems, but I don't think a slide with a woman in underwear is a good example.

Comparisons between the U.S. and France are often dubious, but reading Elaine Sciolino's La Seduction: How the French Play the Game of Life made me rethink some of the issues Koll describes. Sciolino writes, for example:

The game of the sexes also extends deep into the workplace. In the United States, the mildest playfulness during business hours and in a business setting is forbidden; in France, it is encouraged. In American corporations, men are told routinely that they cross the line when they compliment a female employee on the color of her dress or the style of her hair. In France, flirtation is part of the job.

(I wrote more about the book here: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2011/08/09/la-seduction-how-th...).

And her experiences in the French workplace appear to be mostly good. It might be that the U.S. and France are too different to compare, but I also don't think that the asexual approach implicitly endorsed here is right or even practical.

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#84
Jokes are one thing. Good jokes make a point without being demeaning. Good jokes are intelligent. Sexist jokes can be funny and good.

But the examples given in the article are not even jokes, much less good jokes. They are examples of behavior that only objectify women. This is what needs to stop.

A former female coworker of mine had no problem dealing with sexual jokes around the office despite being a modest and conservative person. She just rolled with it. But she called me up to complain one time because she was at a conference where the highlight was lining up to get autographs from the swimsuit models dressed in bikinis. Now, there was absolutely no point in including that activity and since she had no interest in getting that autograph it set her apart from her male colleagues unnecessarily.

Edit: fixed grammar and punctuation

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People laugh when they hear a "racist" joke because it's funny. Maybe race related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about race somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

>I mean, where does this political correctness stop? When you are exclusively in the company of people who know you well enough to tell precisely how ironic you are or aren't being.

Yeah I guess that was a cheap response, but with some validity :-)

There's a big difference between making race/sex jokes with people who realise you are being ironic + actually have no problem with it (I emphasise actually!), vs. when you are actually demeaning someone and they are __in the room__ at the time.

There's definitely a big problem with sexism in our industry (+ elsewhere too clearly.)

A thought experiment: somebody gets up on stage and presents a slide saying 'so simple that even blacks can use it!'

There's a degree to which in any society where it's ok to make 'jokes' or comments with an edge, when the group in question is to some degree subjugated. That still remains the case with women to a large degree, far less so race (at least openly in the west), and 100% is the case with weight. It's worth stopping and taking a look at that.

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#86
post #7

People laugh when they hear a "sexist" joke because it's funny. Maybe gender related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

People laugh when they hear a "racist" joke because it's funny. Maybe race related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about race somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

Yes, there should be place for jokes about race somewhere.

Racism is a different thing than "jokes about race".

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#87
post #7

People laugh when they hear a "sexist" joke because it's funny. Maybe gender related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

This is a topic that comes up in improv a lot - actors want to play a character of a given background (gender, orientation, ethnicity), but don't want it to come off as offensive.

The fact is, it's always possible to be offensive no matter what the actor does.

Anecdotally however, playing a character of a given background becomes offensive when the actor portrays a caricature of the background or the actor speaks or acts in a way that takes away the character's humanity. Therefore, it's typically okay to play a character of a specific background, as long as you stay true to how the character thinks or acts as a human, and not as a caricature or cartoon.

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#88
post #13
post #7

People laugh when they hear a "sexist" joke because it's funny. Maybe gender related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

> but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? Why?

http://s3.postimage.org/ts971lz37/joke.jpg

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#89
post #7

People laugh when they hear a "sexist" joke because it's funny. Maybe gender related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about genders somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

I am open to the idea that openly sexist jokes can be funny, but in those cases, they are funny, because they are explicitly, egregiously offensive, and the laughter ensues because of the awkwardness this creates. British humour (Jimmy Carr) is based on offending, and Louis C.K. have almost made careers out of this. Ricky Gervais did something similar, when he hosted the Golden Globes. The point of his shtick was to make people feel uncomfortable at an event that usually occasions insufferably back-patting and ego-stroking where people hand each other awards and accolades for being amazing, infallible human beings.

The problem arises when sexist jokes aren't regarded as intentionally offensive, and the discourse is internalized to the point where sexism is regarded as being funny, because it's sexism.

I don't see a lot of "funny" racism - if any - in the industry, and I think it's because we've come much farther, when it relates to race - and to some degree sexuality as well.

Comedian Stewart Lee is good at describing this mentality: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xgABbHPdwH4.

Re: Sexism is not funny, let's stop laughing

#90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People laugh when they hear a "racist" joke because it's funny. Maybe race related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about race somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

Not sarcastic: People laugh when they hear a "racist" joke because it's funny. Maybe race related jokes don't have a place at conferences and work places - I am not sure - but there should be room for jokes about race somewhere, right? I mean, where does this political correctness stop?

Er, no.

A joke about race can be very funny, both ways. A racist joke, is just racism.

I'm am not going to down vote you, but I hope you understand the difference.

Post reply on HN