Live data from Hacker News

Coursera course 'Fundamentals of Online Education' closed without warning

chewingthistles.wordpress.com

31–33 of 33 posts

Re: Coursera course 'Fundamentals of Online Education' closed without warning

#31

I don't get it why Coursera can't fix its video player. It's their core technology right? I can't resume videos from where I left, every video just opened for 1 sec. is considered 'watched', to close the video popup on iPad I need to play 'find a close button' game and overall the user experience of watching videos sucks a big way.

Coursera engineer here. Yes, we've seen that the video player can be quite buggy for some. We haven't tracked down all the issues, but some of them seem to be due to the HTML5 browser player not working as well in some browsers. Some people are more successful using the Flash fallback or downloading the videos. We are working on moving to a new video player library and specifically looking at iPad improvements (button placement/clickability). Sorry for your bad experience, and thanks for the feedback.

Re: Coursera course 'Fundamentals of Online Education' closed without warning

#32

It appears the instructor is employed as an "instructional designer" in Georgia Tech's distance learning program. Superficially, traditional distance learning programs have something in common with MOOCs, but there are a number of important differences. An obvious one is scale and it seems like the instructor was legitimately unprepared for the M in MOOC. Unfortunately, (and obviously generalizing here) another one i…

MOOC's have significantly different expectations for quality.

In an average university, there are decent professors successfully teaching students a topic that they know, and have a bunch of years experience in teaching that topic.

But in a MOOC that is not enough - since a single MOOC can scale to almost all the world needs for that subject, there is no need for a thousand professors teaching the same subject, only the best ones. Some things are unavoidably "lost in translation" due to lack of face-time, but a great prof in a MOOC will still be better than the perfectly ok professor at your closest average university.

To do MOOCs the way they should be done, you don't need to "vet the instructor" in the way that teachers or professors are vetted. The quality threshold here is very simple - are you one of top 10 people in the world in your narrow subject area? If not, you don't need to apply.

The great MOOC courses I had were good only because the teachers were far more qualified than any professors teaching the same subject in 500 mile area from me, that is the value-add of MOOCs. The courses would not have been great if they were taught by simply a random good professor from a good university.

Re: Coursera course 'Fundamentals of Online Education' closed without warning

#33

I am in another Coursera course that seems to be experiencing some issues. It seems this whole process is like early beta software (not like gmail "beta" years later...). Which is fine with me as a consumer. I was a bit frustrated that the process wasn't a bit clearer up front. And it does seem they haven't really figured out he huge class size issues yet. It does seem to me it woudl have been better to start out slo…

curiouscats- Just curious, what course are you taking on Coursera thats experiencing similar issues?
Post reply on HN