Live data from Hacker News

A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

marco.org

21–30 of 66 posts

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There is some merit to this comment. I have a Samsung SIII. Perhaps, it is my stubby fingers or short thumb, but I find it difficult to fully use it with just one hand. My previous phone was the HTC Desire, and that was pretty good for using it with one hand.

Different strokes. I have a Nexus 4 and I wish it was a little bigger. I used to have a Desire and it was way too small for me. That's why I'm really glad we aren't all forced to use the same form factor.

> That's why I'm really glad we aren't all forced to use the same form factor.

I'm all for user choice, but unfortunately "choice" doesn't actually seem to be the way the market is trending...

I've been trying to decide what to do when my phone contract comes up for renewal, and want to stay with the same carrier (phone number, contact email, etc).

However, my carrier (au), despite offering 28 (I counted!) different smartphone models, seems to be going whole hog for giant-screen phones, and the smaller phones are all "budget" models with worse quality screens, heavier weight, etc. [The big exception is the iphone, but I want Android.]

The sense one gets is that they consider smaller existing models "leftovers" from the past, and that they'll be pumping up screen sizes even more once they get the chance...

[This is particularly absurd in Japan where hands are smaller on average, and far fewer people drive everywhere than the U.S. (small size and light weight are more important if you've got to carry your phone in your pocket all day as you walk around; if you're driving portability is a bit less of an issue)...]

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#22

This really sucks. I've always enjoyed the small (compared to those out there now) size of iPhone 4. And now it's just slowly getting bigger and bigger. Wished they'd ditch iPhone 5 size, but go ahead with the iPhone plus model, this way those that prefer small and nimble devices gets satisfied too (but then not sure how many of us are out there).

they're not replacing existing models, they're adding another option.

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#24
post #4

Personally - I've used 'large' phones, and I much prefer the size of the iPhone 5. Its big enough but not so big that I can't used it with 1 hand.

I do not understand phablets. I really don't. My Galaxy Nexus is already pushing the limits of what is comfortable to use with one hand, and there is something else that never seems mentioned: Phablets start to get too big for your winter coat pocket, your jean pockets, etc. They simply become uncomfortable to carry, even if you do use them with both hands.

You're supposed to put a phablet in your purse, not your pocket.

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#25
post #2

Samsung innovates and Apple copies, once again.

The term "Phablet" may have been coined to describe the Samsung Note, but that doesn't mean Samsung was the first one who released a large-screen smart phone. The Dell Streak was one of the first, and Windows Phone has the Titan I and II.

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#27
post #12
post #3

If this comes out, the sound of all those years of just I cations and excuses (perfect screen size, perfect jeans pocket size, etc.) Will only be drowned out by the new justifications and excuses (perfect purse size, etc.) Sigh.

Who said it was perfect? I think most agree that about 4 inches is the one-size-fits-all. That means it's best on average, not best for everyone. It's completely OK to introduce new form factors if there's clear demand.

Not many said perfect, but there is the classic example of Dustin Curtis' article which claimed the original iPhone size was "one of the things that makes Apple products Apple products" and got a hell of a lot of traction here and elsewhere. Even this article cops to insulting the Note.

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Different strokes. I have a Nexus 4 and I wish it was a little bigger. I used to have a Desire and it was way too small for me. That's why I'm really glad we aren't all forced to use the same form factor.

> That's why I'm really glad we aren't all forced to use the same form factor. I'm all for user choice, but unfortunately "choice" doesn't actually seem to be the way the market is trending... I've been trying to decide what to do when my phone contract comes up for renewal, and want to stay with the same carrier (phone number, contact email, etc). However, my carrier (au), despite offering 28 (I counted!) different…

Agreed. The Droid M is about the only recent phone that packs a decent amount of power into a smaller phone- and the fact that I'm describing a 4.3" phone as 'smaller' depresses me.

Re: A crazier prediction: iPhone Plus is real, and huge

#29
post #12
post #3

If this comes out, the sound of all those years of just I cations and excuses (perfect screen size, perfect jeans pocket size, etc.) Will only be drowned out by the new justifications and excuses (perfect purse size, etc.) Sigh.

Who said it was perfect? I think most agree that about 4 inches is the one-size-fits-all. That means it's best on average, not best for everyone. It's completely OK to introduce new form factors if there's clear demand.

> Who said it was perfect?

Gruber, for one:

"Apple seems very confident about the precise size and dimensions of the iPhone display: 3.5 inches, with a 3:2 aspect ratio. Not 3 inches. Not 4 inches. [...]

The iPhone 4 feels like a major step toward an idealized iPhone form factor. What defines the iPhone, physically, is the 3.5-inch diagonal screen." [1]

"On These Rumors of a 4.6-Inch iPhone Display [...]

Sure, developers would get on board and support the new size. But why would Apple want to add another vector of fragmentation? For this reason and others, I say it’s bullshit." [2]

"Regarding a Smaller iPhone With the Same Pixel Count [...]

It’s a physical artifact, and the size of the display is what’s important. [...] I really don’t think we’ll see screen sizes other than 3.5 inches" [3]

"Color me skeptical that Apple would introduce another new screen size of any sort." [4]

[1] http://daringfireball.net/2010/06/4

[2] http://daringfireball.net/linked/2012/03/22/46-inch-iphone

[3] http://daringfireball.net/linked/2011/02/20/jin-kim-iphone

[4] http://daringfireball.net/linked/2013/01/08/pixels

Post reply on HN