Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Github for recipes

forkingrecipes.com

51–60 of 103 posts

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#51
post #10

Hey Guys, I'm the creator of Forking Recipes, I'll be happy to answer any questions you have and thanks for taking a look!

I agree with the other commenters: great idea, but needs a designer.

By the way, are you based in Chicago? I met somebody at the Chicago HN meetup last year who was talking about building this exact idea, and I loved the idea back then too. Are you that person by chance?

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#52
post #10

Hey Guys, I'm the creator of Forking Recipes, I'll be happy to answer any questions you have and thanks for taking a look!

I agree with the other commenters: great idea, but needs a designer. By the way, are you based in Chicago? I met somebody at the Chicago HN meetup last year who was talking about building this exact idea, and I loved the idea back then too. Are you that person by chance?

I am actually in Chicago, but I haven't been to a HN meetup so you're probably thinking of someone else.

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#53
post #3

this idea is awesome. The "forking" idea is great for recipes, but you need almost something like a difftool to be able to tell what's different and why? I think with a better UI and way's for users to interact with each other this could be extremely cool. Stick with it and good luck :)

+1 on a diff-tool. Its very hard to tell what's different between the forked recipes. Some sort of short commit-style message on the change would be helpful. (Something like "Added potatoes and carrots" or "Smoked the chicken instead of grilling it")

I really like the idea, but as others have mentioned, it does need some design help.

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#54
This is pretty amazing. I had thought how cool it'd be to have something like this a bunch of times (specially when I want to find simplified curry recipes.)

I seem to recall someone put something similar on HN a few months ago. Any ideas who it was?

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#55
post #49

I like it. It seems you are aiming at geeks. And I think geeks want a powerful search interface and this is why I haven't found a website i really like. I want to make queries like "Recipes with Tomatoes, Paprika but without meat of type soup" or "I only have Garlic, Paprika, bread, Cream, flour, and sugar, eggs and spices , what is the closest meaningful lunch? Not in natural language, but with a interface. Like a t…

Thanks for the idea, I'll give it a try.

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#56
post #52

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with the other commenters: great idea, but needs a designer. By the way, are you based in Chicago? I met somebody at the Chicago HN meetup last year who was talking about building this exact idea, and I loved the idea back then too. Are you that person by chance?

I am actually in Chicago, but I haven't been to a HN meetup so you're probably thinking of someone else.

To the GP, that was probably me. Unfortunately, we never got anything off the ground.

dpick, I'd be happy to share the ideas we were kicking around when thinking about this if you want to shoot me an email: john [at] nineteeneightd.com.

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#57
post #3

this idea is awesome. The "forking" idea is great for recipes, but you need almost something like a difftool to be able to tell what's different and why? I think with a better UI and way's for users to interact with each other this could be extremely cool. Stick with it and good luck :)

There actually is a really basic diff tool right now (Click on revisions on the recipe page). I'm working on creating a more advanced one now. Any ideas on what a good interface might be?

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#58

Very nice! I'd like to have the option (but not the requirement) to log in with oauth(2) from Facebook, Google, Twitter, etc. Your site will get a lot more traction if you implement that, I think. Most people (even non-techie folks) are suffering from account proliferation.

Actually, its been shown that the confusion of which account type to use is worse than the bonus of having options at signup. I forget who did the testing, but non-techies have trouble remembering which they used as well as understanding what it means to "sign in with..".

I'd be interested in seeing the study. For me, at least (and I think for many others) the thought of creating yet another login is enough to make me back out.

Re: Show HN: Github for recipes

#59
I know that twitter boostrap is a great tool to start a project and to prove the concept. I love the idea as a amateur cook and developer (not amateur :D), but if you want to reach a larger public (non developers) I think you should invest some time (and probably money) into a good designer (by the way, is a website where we could really "rent" a webdesigner? I know some where you coul rent a coder but not a designer).
Post reply on HN