Live data from Hacker News

Actual Facebook Graph Searches

actualfacebookgraphsearches.tumblr.com

151–160 of 251 posts

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#151

The searches depicted are more telling about the person making the search rather than the supposed "victims". Nothing to see here, unless you buy into stereotypical fearmongering or are "shocked" that humans are human.

You don't seem to understand the power information has over people's lives. Have you ever disclosed information to some of your friends that you wouldn't disclose to the general public? What about information that could get you arrested or executed? This is real.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How should I know?

You could watch The Ascent of Man by Jacob Bronowski.

Bought this series on DVD recently, only watched a few episodes but it really is great. His presenting style leaves a little to be desired but this is a man of extraordinary intelligence and breadth of knowledge.

If anyone is wondering on the subject matter, it plots of the ascent of man not in terms of biological evolution but cultural evolution - which seems to me to be an oft overlooked facet of how we came to be.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#154

Apple Inc Employees Who Like Android: https://www.facebook.com/search/103818329656399/likers/13794... People who like Barack Obama and Mitt Romney: https://www.facebook.com/search/6815841748/likers/2139280112... People who like MPAA and The Pirate Bay: https://www.facebook.com/search/108476252505746/likers/11101...

[deleted]

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#155
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I appreciate the information, but this misses the point. Facebook hides privacy settings because privacy is bad for their business objectives, and most people will never bother to dig for these settings, leaving them open to the kinds of attacks demonstrated by the original post.

> Facebook hides privacy settings I have a direct link to privacy settings in the header. I don't know how can they make it more visible.

Chart me a path from the privacy settings dialog in the header to changing the visibility of individual "likes", such that the average user can prepare to hide from random strangers when Open Graph Search goes public.

I dare you.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#156
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Nothing good can come out of applying dumb algorithms (that is, any algorithm) to a sufficiently rich "social graph"; it will always lead to situations like that which are, at best, embarrassing, and at worst, dangerous, for whoever is in the system. What does this even mean? The "dumb algorithm" here will (a) take a user's query and (b) search that user's friends and public profiles for hits on that query. What's ne…

> If you don't like it, then quit. Assuming you're socially allowed to quit Facebook.

Quitting Facebook is really not that big of a deal. You won't become a social pariah, an outcast or loose all your friends because you cancel a website account.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So you're a fan of data, that's fair enough. Who isn't a fan of data? The issue is, who owns and controls that data? You, the true owner and source of the data, or some big advertising-driven tech giant with it's own crappy hollywood movie? Not only that, but in order to make money from advertising, they link all this wonderful data (your data) with advertiser interests. Much of this linking is done under the radar,…

What, in your opinion, would be an appropriate platform?

What zxcdw said. :-) Also, my previous post has typo, should read "IMHO FB is not currently an appropriate platform"... damn what a bad typo,.

The thing is, Facebook could be better by allowing members to invite outside data to flow into their feeds from chosen sources, and providing more freedom with data-exchange in general. Enforced segregation is costly.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#158
post #121

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just did the same. I've had enough of being used.

You realize graph search only utilizes information that YOU make available. Why did you make that data available? Do you not want others to see it? If you didn't, then why did you put it out there for others to see? Also, you know that privacy controls are taken into account right? So if you don't make certain data available to certain people, you don't show up in searches for those people.... I think you're being a…

Yes I do but when I joined facebook I didn't realize they would create a super search engine to easily sort and categorize all of their users' data for more efficient targeted advertising. They sell likes, they have my friends sponsor ads they've never sponsored, they used 5 of my friends pictures to try to manipulate me into not deleting my account. We aren't their main customer but are there just to be targeted. Sounds like we are being used.

This graph search is just the last straw. It is terrifying the repercussions this search engine could have, and I believe this blog post shows some great examples.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#159
post #85

Short term this may be a problem, but long term it's probably a good thing. Hopefully once people become aware of what they're exposing they'll become more cautious. Complaining about News Feed and Graph Search is basically saying you're ok with "security through obscurity". If I understand correctly, all of this information is already available to those who want to dig deep enough.

While it's (probably) true that the information is already available, it's not easily available. If it's going to take me 25 days of tedious profile reading to find people who I seek (e.g. "Lesbian women from Greece who like Doritos"), I'm not going to do it. It's not practically available. Graph Search changes that. Obscurity vanishes, along with any security it provided.

By 25 days of profile reading, I think you mean 2 days of writing a scraper and 10 days of tuning it? The rest being spent letting it run, reading hacker news, reddit, and your friends' facebook updates.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#160
post #97

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you don't like it, then quit. Assuming you're socially allowed to quit Facebook.

Quitting Facebook is really not that big of a deal. You won't become a social pariah, an outcast or loose all your friends because you cancel a website account.

You might well lose touch with a geographically diverse crowd of people. FB and the like keep people involved in the minutiae of each others lives and very much help keep real friendships alive.

Of course FB is trying to destroy this as much as possible by controlling what you see of what people post. Trying to decide what's important to me is another facet of the 'dumb' algorithms the OP complains about.

Post reply on HN