Live data from Hacker News

Actual Facebook Graph Searches

actualfacebookgraphsearches.tumblr.com

11–20 of 251 posts

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#11
post #6

This is bad news all around. It is likely a huge percentage of searches performed by people will not enrich lives but most people will use it to mine out insights that others don't wish to be publicized. Can you imagine people being rounded up in China over this and put into prisons over their "like".

You don't even have to imagine, it's already happened.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#12
post #6

This is bad news all around. It is likely a huge percentage of searches performed by people will not enrich lives but most people will use it to mine out insights that others don't wish to be publicized. Can you imagine people being rounded up in China over this and put into prisons over their "like".

You don't even have to imagine, it's already happened.

Do you have a link with more information?

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#13
post #5

With great power comes great responsibility. Companies such as Facebook and the like undoubtedly draw great power from their "social graph"; however, human interactions are subtle, complex, multifaceted and often contradictory. Nothing good can come out of applying dumb algorithms (that is, any algorithm) to a sufficiently rich "social graph"; it will always lead to situations like that which are, at best, embarrassi…

[deleted]

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#15
post #5

With great power comes great responsibility. Companies such as Facebook and the like undoubtedly draw great power from their "social graph"; however, human interactions are subtle, complex, multifaceted and often contradictory. Nothing good can come out of applying dumb algorithms (that is, any algorithm) to a sufficiently rich "social graph"; it will always lead to situations like that which are, at best, embarrassi…

I hate to flip the script on social networking, but I think google is doing a pretty good job with focusing on exploration and compartmentalization of friends and social groups in +. Maybe something like graph search is their eventual intention, but I really hope their vision is less...disastrous.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#17
post #6

This is bad news all around. It is likely a huge percentage of searches performed by people will not enrich lives but most people will use it to mine out insights that others don't wish to be publicized. Can you imagine people being rounded up in China over this and put into prisons over their "like".

They don't have Facebook in the Great Firewall of China.

And if they DID, people there wouldn't be liking Falun Gong. It's a bogus example.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#18
Short term this may be a problem, but long term it's probably a good thing. Hopefully once people become aware of what they're exposing they'll become more cautious.

Complaining about News Feed and Graph Search is basically saying you're ok with "security through obscurity". If I understand correctly, all of this information is already available to those who want to dig deep enough.

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#19
> “Islamic men interested in men who live in Tehran, Iran“

This is funny, in Iran people don't quite understand what "interested in" means. In sign up process when they see "interested in" options, they think that means "are you interested in finding friends who are male?" (same for females). This is because:

1. People use VPN to access Facebook and Facebook can not localize/internationalize their experience.

2. Using translated Facebook sucks(at least translated in Farsi)

3. Concept of homosexual relationships is not known by many iranians because of lack of education.

So there is no wonder if people in Iran marking themself gay while they are not.

(with all respect to gay people)

Re: Actual Facebook Graph Searches

#20

Consider: “Family members of people who live in China and like Falun Gong”. And: ”When users recognize or fear that their privacy or confidentiality is compromised, true freedom of inquiry no longer exists.” - American Library Association, http://www.ala.org/Template.cfm?Section=interpretations&...

Where's the EFF Panopticlick for your FB likes? To tell you how well you stick out or blend in with the crowd? (though blending in with the crowd is just security through obscurity...) A couple days ago someone was asking for an automated FB deliker app/service, to automatically unlike everything you've like d on FB.

Best to just set it up so "Only you" can see your own likes.

http://abrax.us/Facebook/EditLikes.php

Post reply on HN