Live data from Hacker News

Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

consideronline.org

1–10 of 60 posts

Re: Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

#3
post #2

I wrote the counterpoint, and although I really respect Professor Holloway's point, I really think his argument is stuck too much in the past.

I think you're young and ignorant, you should stay and school and gain perspective before moving to the real world.

Re: Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

#6
post #4

As a college student, I'm always torn about whether or not it is worth it to get my CS degree. Sometimes, my classes seem really useless, but at other times, I feel like I'm learning a lot socially at college.

I felt the same way during my business undergrad -- everything I was learning, from CAPM to Deming's management ideas to queue theory and operations management, has a wiki page and at least a dozen very good blog posts. Essentially all we're paying for is someone with domain experience to tell us what's relevant to learn, and help us learn it.

How expensive is college if we take away tuition? Is a college really more than just an employment agency for professors, an agency that provides its own classrooms and spaces?

Re: Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

#7
post #4

As a college student, I'm always torn about whether or not it is worth it to get my CS degree. Sometimes, my classes seem really useless, but at other times, I feel like I'm learning a lot socially at college.

I felt the same way during my business undergrad -- everything I was learning, from CAPM to Deming's management ideas to queue theory and operations management, has a wiki page and at least a dozen very good blog posts. Essentially all we're paying for is someone with domain experience to tell us what's relevant to learn, and help us learn it. How expensive is college if we take away tuition? Is a college really more…

~10k/year in housing

Re: Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

#9
post #4

As a college student, I'm always torn about whether or not it is worth it to get my CS degree. Sometimes, my classes seem really useless, but at other times, I feel like I'm learning a lot socially at college.

It all depends on how good of a HS education you got. It also depends on the fun and relationships you are having outside of your school work. For me that was the best part

Re: Is University Necessary? A professor debates a student.

#10
post #4

As a college student, I'm always torn about whether or not it is worth it to get my CS degree. Sometimes, my classes seem really useless, but at other times, I feel like I'm learning a lot socially at college.

Unless you have a revolutionary and marketable idea and are 110% confident about executing it with the utmost discipline that will guarantee something that you can call "success", please stay in school. Sorry if my tone is dick-ish - I'm just sick and tired of these debates about the value of college.
Post reply on HN