Live data from Hacker News

Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

blog.achernya.com

61–70 of 220 posts

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#61

To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. The whole point of a protest is to put pressure on the system your trying to change. Start a walkout/go on strike if you dont want to deal with the problems the organization you're working for caused. The school only gets power from its students. Without the students there is no…

[deleted]

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#62

To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. The whole point of a protest is to put pressure on the system your trying to change. Start a walkout/go on strike if you dont want to deal with the problems the organization you're working for caused. The school only gets power from its students. Without the students there is no…

>To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work.

Are black people notorious for eating or something? That kind of came out of left field, there.

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#64
post #45

As I'd mentioned on an earlier submission about W3C's site being inaccessible: A cool thing about Aaron's activism was that it involved building things, circumventing censorship, and spreading information, rather than sabotage and denial-of-service.

True but Aaron's activism resulted in him being bullied until he took his own life. It's a difficult topic. If you assume that ddos from a collective is similar to blocking a road by a collective during a strike or manifestation then I must say that some people won't be able to get to work that day and in general nobody would get hurt. This sort of pacific interruption raises awareness, which by itself is very import…

But why protest student blogs and class websites? Why not target the prosecutor's office?

Blockading a key port that is shipping war supplies or preforming a DDOS attack against government websites can be legitimate form of protest, but those actions are very hard to plan and pull off.

This attack (if it is an attack) just seems like someone is going after the low-hanging fruit of MIT's network.

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#65

Please let me read your blog page without needed to turn on lots of javascript. The page is blank without whitelisting JS content.

This is as expected. If you want to disable the browser, you should a blank page. Javascript is as much a part of web content as html.

If you're worried about security, run Linux or OSX as your operating system.

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#66

If the students have failed to vehemently distance themselves and protest to the administration, or even quit MIT for somewhere else, then they are just as guilty. Their attendance abets the status quo. Especially since it's a private university. Quit whining.

That's insane. There's no way an individual student can possibly vet and approve every decision made by the school administration. If the U.S. president engages is an immoral action do I bear the guilt of his actions because I voted for him? Should I renounce my U.S. citizenship whenever my congress-critter misbehaves? Of course not. That is the worst thing I could do. I would be far more effective if I stuck around and campaigned against an immoral leader and tried to get a replacement elected.

I imagine the point of this attack is to effect/inconvenience students so they complain to the MIT administration. The school bureaucracy won't listen to random strangers on the internet, but they will listen to students.

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#67

My guess is someone wants to "send a message" to MIT and so they're attacking the most vulnerable, most exploitable part of MIT's infrastructure: a non-critical system run by student volunteers. I doubt it's anything personal against Alex or other MIT students. Imagine if a thousand members of Anonymous staged a non-violent protest at MIT, marching across campus. This would inconvenience some students, possibly even…

Why is it perfectly acceptable to inconvenience people from their studies? Man, this kind of attitude makes me want to encourage harsher penalties on people who pull this bullshit. You do your movement no favours when you inconvenience the same people you want on your side.

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#68
post #62

To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. The whole point of a protest is to put pressure on the system your trying to change. Start a walkout/go on strike if you dont want to deal with the problems the organization you're working for caused. The school only gets power from its students. Without the students there is no…

>To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. Are black people notorious for eating or something? That kind of came out of left field, there.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greensboro_sit-ins

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#69
post #62

To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. The whole point of a protest is to put pressure on the system your trying to change. Start a walkout/go on strike if you dont want to deal with the problems the organization you're working for caused. The school only gets power from its students. Without the students there is no…

>To me this feels a bit like a lunch counter cook complaining all these black people showing up in his restaurant are causing him extra work. Are black people notorious for eating or something? That kind of came out of left field, there.

I think it is referring to the sit-ins that occurred in the 60s.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sit-ins#Civil_Rights_Movement

Re: Please Stop Attacking MIT's Network

#70
post #14

I do not condone the attacks that may be occurring. However, if you are trying to get someone's attention- it makes more sense to get the attention of the students rather than the administration. Today's MIT students are tomorrow's death-ray designers, robot-maintainers, and policy makers. They are tomorrow's administration- and they may not have made up their minds yet about ethical issues of intellectual property o…

If you're trying to simply "get the attention" of the student body, congratulations you have it.

If you're trying to get the student body on your side, you're doing the exact opposite. If I pay $X/year to attend an institution, and someone wants to fuck with my ability to learn to further their own political goals (no matter how noble) you're not winning me over.

Post reply on HN