Live data from Hacker News

The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

theatlantic.com

181–190 of 261 posts

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#181

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yep, will never read anything from the atlantic again, just added it to my host file.

Isn't that a bit much?

Nah, I'd prefer my news sources not report based on who gives the most money. There are plenty of other options.

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#182
post #14

>Sponsor Content is created by The Atlantic’s Promotions Department in partnership with our advertisers. The Atlantic editorial team is not involved in the creation of this content. Email advertising@theatlantic.com to learn more. So if the Taliban wanted to pay for content they would be fine with that too.

>>Sponsor Content is created by The Atlantic’s Promotions Department in partnership with our advertisers.

So The Atlantic actually created this content and some nebulous "advertisers" were mere partners?

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#183
post #122

Without delving into the specifics of Scientology, I am reminded of a grellas quotation: "The most valuable asset of a lawyer is his reputation." This applies to some journalistic endeavors as well. In some cases, I seek out the thoughts of those whose facts are unreliable, because their opinions are interesting or novel. But just as often, I seek out long-form, descriptive pieces to learn what reliable people believ…

Judging by this sponsored story, it seems that the people running The Atlantic have already decided to turn this august publication into an "interesting" brand. It's a shame. What doesn't make sense to me is that The Atlantic supposedly became profitable a couple of years ago -- see http://www.nytimes.com/2010/12/13/business/media/13atlantic.... -- which, if true, means they didn't actually need to do this!

I like The Atlantic but they also got themselves banned from reddit for spamming their stories. (after people were already raving about the site regardless)

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#184
post #58

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The true story of scientology has already been told. A mediocre sci-fi author realized he could make a lot of money by inventing a bullshit story [1] and then proceeded to recruit a bunch of brownshirts [2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xenu [2] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5055604 And frankly, I think it's high time to kick them the fuck out of Berlin, at the very least. We tried radiating the cancer; it'…

I don't disagree, but it is socially unacceptable to say such things about thugs in other religions, just Scientology - and they may be freely promoted in the press with equal quantities of distortion - this bothers me a great deal.

Why is this relevant? It's irrelevant to Scientology's abuses and untrue. If we had the opportunity to shut down Christianity's past and current abuses, we should pursue this, whether Christianity "did it too" does not need to be brought up in every article.

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#185
post #86

Contra the best article they ever ran... what's next? Why diamonds actually are scarce and valuable, sponsored by deBeers. ??!!

Amusing considering that one of their greatest articles (to my recollection) was http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/1982/02/have-you...

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#186

Please consider writing a letter to the Editor (at this url: http://www.theatlantic.com/contact/ ). Here's what I wrote: Hello, I've been very disappointed by Atlantic's decision to run the Scientology promo article under sponsored content ( http://www.theatlantic.com/sponsored/scientology/archive/201... ). Despite the small label on top saying "Sponsored content" and a banner at the very bottom, which needs to be sc…

A friend of mine just became an associate editor at the Atlantic. He's a good guy, rational and open minded, I sent him this URL and the story URL. I'll be interested to see what he comes back with on the issue privately.

You should go ahead and ask your friend for a copy of his resume, too, because he might be needing it passed around before too long.

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#187
post #68

And if a pro-Scientology adverticle wasn't enough, every page has at the top "A Wonderful New Book About Scientology, By a Wonderful WriterJeffrey Goldberg". I'm sure this other article is totally not related to the sponsored content.

This appears to be a sarcastic response by Goldberg to the presence of the advertorial. The book he's talking about is quite critical of Scientology.

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#189

Yeah, but read the content of what is actually up on the site. It's patently transparent bullshit. "All we do is open buildings! Everything is wonderful in out world! Banner year!" It makes the church look even MORE cultish. The motives are obvious: they're getting hit thanks to the new Lawrence Wright book, so they respond with this utterly idiotic pap. It's amazing that to me that they think ANYONE would actually b…

Then why are they deleting any negative comments? If they're trying to distance themselves from the North Korea-level bullshit they're publishing for cash, the best way to strike back would be to allow users to respond without being silenced in the name of their advertisers.

Re: The Atlantic posts sponsored Scientology story, moderates comments

#190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Finally the true story of scientology is being told!

An insidious evil, thought defeated, but quietly gathering strength.

Right, they're still sitting on a LOT of real estate tax-free. They can weather 4chan's disrespect and bide their time until say, loyalist Will Smith decides to "come out" in their favor, gaining a ton of new celeb-obsessed converts.
Post reply on HN