Live data from Hacker News

Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

reutersconnect.com

71–80 of 109 posts

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#71

FWIW, Naza appears to be a fairly in depth documentary where Israeli soldiers give detailed accounts on how the Gaza war worked from the inside, including expansive targets, and well known high civilian death toll.

The immediate response to the 10/7 infiltration attack was extremely lethal to Israelis as well, something not well covered outside of Israeli media.

28 helicopters emptied their internal stores of 30mm autocannon and Hellfires that day, with many RTB to rearm/refuel, all of them at dense Israeli territory. Seven of them dumped their entire stores into Moshav Tkuma. To this day all deaths there are tallied to the infiltrators, with the exception of Efrat Katz. Rapid bulldozer burial of damaged vehicles and buildings was also performed, as the damage from those weapons is very distinctive. Not a gesture of honesty, that.

Tanks were also instructed to fire their main armament into houses known to have civilians inside. Israeli corpses were, again, tallied to infiltrators; any non-Israeli corpses tallied as hostile.

Pilots, soldiers, tankists, and UAS operators all asked over the radio for targets that day, but were simply directed to apply maximal fires to anything that moved in a Palestinian-like way. Hannibal was cited as justification. The Israeli Hannibal operational order, which directs the use of force to prevent soldiers being taken into captivity, was apparently being cited over the air to justify the deaths of civilians. An extreme distortion, but one which Israelis are increasingly making their peace with, alongside many others.

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#72
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not defending Israel as the minister is clearly wrong here, but surely silencing critics by killing them (what Iran is accused of) is quite a bit more severe than removing citizenship?

Funniest comment I’ve read all day, thanks. Never seen someone make light of a government rendering someone stateless. Especially rich in the context of an apartheid state.

Are you saying your own comment is funniest your read all day? If not then I am quite confused because I never made light of anything and made it clear that it was the wrong thing to do. I just think comparing murder and removing citizenship is not a great comparison.

If anybody made light of anything it was the person I was responding to.

Israel has murdered journalists in Gaza. That would be the better comparison to Iran's actions. I don't think Israel removing citizenship has an equal comparison with anything Iran has done.

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#73

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

The cope is thinking Israel would survive without the fanatical material support the west gives it now. Anyway, have fun going on about your Lebensborn. We all know how well that worked out for your predecessors.

[flagged]

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#74

FWIW, Naza appears to be a fairly in depth documentary where Israeli soldiers give detailed accounts on how the Gaza war worked from the inside, including expansive targets, and well known high civilian death toll.

The immediate response to the 10/7 infiltration attack was extremely lethal to Israelis as well, something not well covered outside of Israeli media. 28 helicopters emptied their internal stores of 30mm autocannon and Hellfires that day, with many RTB to rearm/refuel, all of them at dense Israeli territory. Seven of them dumped their entire stores into Moshav Tkuma. To this day all deaths there are tallied to the inf…

please tell me how you got this info

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The cope is thinking Israel would survive without the fanatical material support the west gives it now. Anyway, have fun going on about your Lebensborn. We all know how well that worked out for your predecessors.

[flagged]

Tell that to the many jewish cultures that were eradicated by the Nazis in Europe.

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#78
post #10

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are confusing the current government with Israel. It’s the same as with the USA, the current government isn’t the USA.

You will find that 95% of Israelis support the actions of the IDF in this war regardless of how they feel about Netanyahu or his coalition.

its a bit above 80% really.

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#79

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Now we're advocating ethnic cleansing of Zionist Jews from New York City?

By definition if you are a Zionist Jew you would not be living in New York or anywhere outside of Israel, if you had the means to do so which nearly all Jews do given the support from the Israeli government, they will even pay for your flight.

No, that's not the "definition".

Re: Israeli Minister Threatens Filmmakers' Citizenship over Gaza Documentary

#80

FWIW, Naza appears to be a fairly in depth documentary where Israeli soldiers give detailed accounts on how the Gaza war worked from the inside, including expansive targets, and well known high civilian death toll.

The immediate response to the 10/7 infiltration attack was extremely lethal to Israelis as well, something not well covered outside of Israeli media. 28 helicopters emptied their internal stores of 30mm autocannon and Hellfires that day, with many RTB to rearm/refuel, all of them at dense Israeli territory. Seven of them dumped their entire stores into Moshav Tkuma. To this day all deaths there are tallied to the inf…

This is a conspiracy that has next to no evidence to support its claims. Judging by your usage of extremely lethal im going to guess you think a significant % of the deaths that day were friendly fire. IDF have addressed both the friendly fire instances and the deaths were 14
Post reply on HN