Live data from Hacker News

Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

rmoff.net

51–60 of 112 posts

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#51

I had previously used seaweedfs, which has more moving parts but seems more feature-rich. It was overkill for a homelab, so I went to garage. Garage is very stable, but the metadata engine / file MUST live on NVMe. Otherwise it gets slow on small files. It also lacks features like per bucket retention settings and stuff. It really is "just" a S3 bucket.

The trouble I had with SeaweedFS was that the docs I found were rather sparse. Garage, on the other hand seemed pretty well documented.

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#54

I use JuiceFS https://github.com/juicedata/juicefs if you think the Chinese are worth the trust

In the decades that open-source projects have existed on GitHub—even those backed by the Chinese government—there has never been an instance of them containing spyware; conversely, we frequently see NSA hacking tools exploiting open-source projects to launch massive cyberattacks and cause data breaches. Reality isn't like American movies where Americans are always the heroes; in fact, those GIs are usually the ones doing the invading. To me, your statement sounds like a resident living under Nazi rule telling everyone, "There's actually a pretty good project over on the Allied side—if you choose to believe it."

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#55

Often just spinning up `localstack` works well, even if only for S3. Gives you other AWS services if you ever need them.

Commercial use requires a paid subscription. Probably not an issue for a home lab, unless you run a small business on it.

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#56

I had previously used seaweedfs, which has more moving parts but seems more feature-rich. It was overkill for a homelab, so I went to garage. Garage is very stable, but the metadata engine / file MUST live on NVMe. Otherwise it gets slow on small files. It also lacks features like per bucket retention settings and stuff. It really is "just" a S3 bucket.

For testing/dev setups you can turn sync off and get some performance back but that's only useful for cases where losing data is okay.

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#57
post #2

Just use the damn file system. Why does everyone have to put HTTP between everything?

I can pay Amazon pennies on the dollar to saturate 100Gbps with arbitrarily high concurrency

Sometimes I also want a smaller version for when I don't need that performance but don't want multiple implementations of storage backends

Edit: before someone says NVMe, highly available across 3 fault domains

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#58
post #38

> 2026-03-02: Ruohang Feng has forked MinIO to pgsty/minio and is promising to maintain a stable, CVE-patched, distribution. This is what I went with. I use it in end to end tests as an S3 simulator that starts and stops instantly and reads & writes to a local directory, - as you'd expect it's great in that role. No complaints. Given the fork's maintainer puts their real name on it & stakes their reputation, you'd as…

According to https://github.com/pgsty/silo it's pgsty/silo now: > Renamed from pgsty/minio to pgsty/silo, default branch master → main, on 2026-08-06

This is what I use. I had a minio instance that was replaced flawlessly with silo. This is an excellent project and needs more traction. All existing minio users must switch to Silo ASAP.

Re: Alternatives to MinIO for single-node local S3

#60

I use JuiceFS https://github.com/juicedata/juicefs if you think the Chinese are worth the trust

In the decades that open-source projects have existed on GitHub—even those backed by the Chinese government—there has never been an instance of them containing spyware; conversely, we frequently see NSA hacking tools exploiting open-source projects to launch massive cyberattacks and cause data breaches. Reality isn't like American movies where Americans are always the heroes; in fact, those GIs are usually the ones d…

https://www.npr.org/2024/02/22/1233178131/leaked-document-tr...
Post reply on HN