Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

neobrutalism.dev

61–70 of 70 posts

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#61
post #8

I enjoy the look of these, but personally I wouldn't have thought to describe them as neobrutalist, so I'm thinking I don't know what it is. How is brutalism defined in this context? When I think web brutalism I think Craigslist style sites and reduction of superfluous design elements.

Yeah, I can't stand these influencer-wannabe web-devs misusing terms. béton brut means "raw concrete" in French, and in architecture that's what brutalism is. I'd say only sites that look like they use the default style of HTML with no CSS on Netscape 1.x could be called "brutalist"... E.g. https://stallman.org IMO the design is more "Windows 3.1 Hot Dog Stand Theme" https://blog.codinghorror.com/a-tribute-to-the-win…

I instantly thought of Nielsen's personal homepage - http://useit.com - which has moved on to a little softer and corporate design - but still linger in the Internet Archive:

1996:

https://web.archive.org/web/19961227172043/http://www.useit....

2001:

https://web.archive.org/web/20010711195207/http://www.useit....

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#62
This is insanely verbose just for a button with a tooltip:

  import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button"
  import {
    Tooltip,
    TooltipContent,
    TooltipProvider,
    TooltipTrigger,
  } from "@/components/ui/tooltip"
 
  export default function TooltipDemo() {
    return (
      
        
          }>
            Hover
          
          
            

Add to library

) }
Contrast with plain old HTML form button where the title attribute gives the tooltip text:

  Hover

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#63
post #41
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you're building apps for people who are also in tech, your users won't have any idea what UI styles different LLMs push.

That might be true for them to know it was AI. Which yes, was how I worded it. But not necessarily good enough for it to be differentiated from everything else. For example, in the Bootstrap days everything looked like Bootstrap and users got used to that, even if users hadn't specifically heard of the CSS framework.

I meant to say it was NOT how I worded it!

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#64
post #41
post #9

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Unless you're building apps for people who are also in tech, your users won't have any idea what UI styles different LLMs push.

That might be true for them to know it was AI. Which yes, was how I worded it. But not necessarily good enough for it to be differentiated from everything else. For example, in the Bootstrap days everything looked like Bootstrap and users got used to that, even if users hadn't specifically heard of the CSS framework.

I think I could use those charts and still give my site its own look. I get the Bootstrap comparison though.

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#65

This is insanely verbose just for a button with a tooltip: import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button" import { Tooltip, TooltipContent, TooltipProvider, TooltipTrigger, } from "@/components/ui/tooltip" export default function TooltipDemo() { return ( }> Hover Add to library ) } Contrast with plain old HTML form button where the title attribute gives the tooltip text: Hover

Yeah but can your tooltip render in neon brown?

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#66
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

FWIW, from the OP website: > Neobrutalism is a mix of regular brutalism in web design and more modern typography, illustration, and animation standards. Neobrutalism refuses the usual components of UX-UI design and embraces uncomfortable design elements, and it is more fearless to use distinctive color palettes.

nothing about this is neobrutalist by their own standards. There is nothing “uncomfortable” about these standard round flat shapes, and unvibrant 3/4 saturated tones, they aren’t distinct, its called Alegria[1], calling it neobrutalism is a corruption of the meaning of brutalism and comes off as distinctly uncultured. neobrutalism should have sharp edges, very vibrant saturated colors, and virtually none of these flo…

I don’t necessarily think it’s doing something wildly new and different, but I also don’t see how this style looks anything like what’s in that Wikipedia article.

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#68

This is insanely verbose just for a button with a tooltip: import { Button } from "@/components/ui/button" import { Tooltip, TooltipContent, TooltipProvider, TooltipTrigger, } from "@/components/ui/tooltip" export default function TooltipDemo() { return ( }> Hover Add to library ) } Contrast with plain old HTML form button where the title attribute gives the tooltip text: Hover

Yeah but can your tooltip render in neon brown?

Not sure; it may be doable remotely with some CSS, in which case it would be a few lines of code for any number of buttons.

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#69
Doesn't this tell you to stop using this style? It was fresh a few years ago when examples started popping up (Figma) but now Gemini churns it out and there are tons of templates and libraries that use the most common styling. It's not fun when there's a component library and everyone's site looks like it came from the same template.

Brutalist web design (which is really popular with artists, musicians and designers) is a beautiful style that leaves a lot of room for creativity, whereas this stuff is formulaic garbage.

Re: Show HN: Neobrutalism.dev – Just added Base UI support and added new color theme

#70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah but can your tooltip render in neon brown?

Not sure; it may be doable remotely with some CSS, in which case it would be a few lines of code for any number of buttons.

Joking aside, I don’t believe you can and I’m fine with that. It’s still so much simpler and predictable.
Post reply on HN