Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

livven.me

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

1–10 of 52 posts

Re: ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

#3

Post by Livven »

meaty wrote: post #2

This is the sort of reason I buy my stuff from Amazon / 7digital. The mp3 container format has no provision for DRM so it cannot be abused.

Well yeah theoretically you're safer but Apple announced that iTunes music would become completely DRM-free back in 2009. And they've kept their promise, up until now that is. I don't think anybody thought they'd sneak it back in. I was really surprised when I found out they did. Hope it's just a glitch they'll fix soon.

Re: ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

#5

Post by meaty »

Livven wrote: post #3
meaty wrote: post #2

This is the sort of reason I buy my stuff from Amazon / 7digital. The mp3 container format has no provision for DRM so it cannot be abused.

Well yeah theoretically you're safer but Apple announced that iTunes music would become completely DRM-free back in 2009. And they've kept their promise, up until now that is. I don't think anybody thought they'd sneak it back in. I was really surprised when I found out they did. Hope it's just a glitch they'll fix soon.

Yes I was there then - in fact I had a load of DRM'ed tracks from iTunes back when I owned an iPod.

Why would you trust Apple not to do it though? They haven't exactly been trustworthy on any front over the years.

Re: ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

#6

Post by michaelfeathers »

Livven wrote: post #3
meaty wrote: post #2

This is the sort of reason I buy my stuff from Amazon / 7digital. The mp3 container format has no provision for DRM so it cannot be abused.

Well yeah theoretically you're safer but Apple announced that iTunes music would become completely DRM-free back in 2009. And they've kept their promise, up until now that is. I don't think anybody thought they'd sneak it back in. I was really surprised when I found out they did. Hope it's just a glitch they'll fix soon.

I wonder whether there is a hidden clause in the EULA. If not, this could be legal trouble.

Re: ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

#7

Post by rickmb »

And this once again is why I still prefer to "pirate" music.

Most "legal" services are either very vague about format, quality and DRM, not available in my country and/or have a limited collection.

The effort involved in buying something legally and DRM-free is just ridiculous, and the notion that I can trust pirates more to be honest, transparent and upfront about their offering really takes the cake.

Only in the copyright exploitation industry is the legal business more shady than the "criminals".

Re: ITunes “album only” tracks are now DRM-protected

#8

Post by rickmb »

meaty wrote: post #2

This is the sort of reason I buy my stuff from Amazon / 7digital. The mp3 container format has no provision for DRM so it cannot be abused.

Just to be sure I checked Amazon before writing my "pro piracy" rant elsewhere. It's a) not available in my country, and b) between any specific mp3 offering and telling me the usual "fuck of, you're from the wrong country", and no point does Amazon inform me about the nature and quality of the download, other than the mp3 format.

Yeah, I can infer the fact that it is non-DRM from the mp3 format, but other than that it's still shadier and less informative than the average piracy side.

Not to mention insulting and utterly useless to me and 16 million fellow countrymen in one of the richest Western nations, were, oh surprise, piracy rules.

Post reply on HN