Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

clashreport.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

61–70 of 97 posts

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#61

Post by quikoa »

3eb7988a1663 wrote: post #36

What is more difficult, building a military missile or the software that runs it? If they are already building weapons, not sure the software to run them was the impediment. Presumably, the world used dumb munitions without any software for a long time.

> What is more difficult, building a military missile or the software that runs it?

"If software was easier compared to building the a missile then Anthropic is in the clear or something." Is that the line of reasoning to protect Anthropic from any wrongdoing?

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#62

Post by Gud »

itsdesmond wrote: post #53
3eb7988a1663 wrote: post #36

What is more difficult, building a military missile or the software that runs it? If they are already building weapons, not sure the software to run them was the impediment. Presumably, the world used dumb munitions without any software for a long time.

It’s the software. Definitely. We been making bombs for a while now. They used to toss them out the side of biplanes. Oddly, your second paragraph immediately undermines the first. > Presumably, the world used dumb munitions without any software for a long time. What do you think “presumably” is accomplishing here? Are you unsure, but willing to assume for purpose of the discussion, that bombs preceded computers?

We've been making PID loops for a lot longer.

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#63

Post by webern777 »

morkalork wrote: post #24

Eventually these products are going to be uselessly nerfed to anyone studying above a highschool level. Can't ask about advanced biology, you might be engineering a virus. Can't ask about chemistry because you might be manufacturing drugs. Can't ask about physics, navigation etc. because you could be building missiles.

Fable 5.1 has a much better classifier for biology than when it came out. It has no problem talking about the chemistry of cell signaling pathways. When it first came out even basic biology questions were tripping the guard rails but not now.

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#64

Post by michelb »

chasd00 wrote: post #38

We need a new DARPA challenge to see what can be done with these ai models and weapon design. Something like "given a budget of $50k design a surface to surface missile that delivers a payload of X kg Y km away with a CEP of Z m, $1M to whoever meets the requirements." because I could use a million dollars. idk if most know how straightforward this is these days even without AI. I would grab an embedded controls guy…

It’s probably the influence of the current American administration, but I find all these AI weapons projects and startups so unbelievably uninspiring. Same with the fighting robots. We finally have a somewhat intelligent AI and we’re not advancing our healthcare, personal care, environmental problems, speeding up construction, finding new materials, etc.

The first one that gets to AGI will make the world worse instead of better. Depressing.

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#65

Post by chrisjj »

dismalaf wrote: post #17

If Anthropic has all this data that Claude was being used by the Houthis to develop a missile guidance system, why the fuck did they allow it? Linux follows international sanctions in not allowing citizens of certain countries to be involved in any way, why isn't Anthropic following the law? Also, why will Anthropic end a session when you use colourful language to admonish it yet apparently just knowingly allows terr…

> If Anthropic has all this data that Claude was being used by the Houthis to develop a missile guidance system, why the fuck did they allow it?

Following Dept of War orders?

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#67

Post by Avicebron »

michelb wrote: post #64
chasd00 wrote: post #38

We need a new DARPA challenge to see what can be done with these ai models and weapon design. Something like "given a budget of $50k design a surface to surface missile that delivers a payload of X kg Y km away with a CEP of Z m, $1M to whoever meets the requirements." because I could use a million dollars. idk if most know how straightforward this is these days even without AI. I would grab an embedded controls guy…

It’s probably the influence of the current American administration, but I find all these AI weapons projects and startups so unbelievably uninspiring. Same with the fighting robots. We finally have a somewhat intelligent AI and we’re not advancing our healthcare, personal care, environmental problems, speeding up construction, finding new materials, etc. The first one that gets to AGI will make the world worse instea…

Destruction is easy and entropically rewarded. We've long since lost our way in rewarding and recognizing things that are positive.

Howl by Ginsberg needs a rewrite. "The greatest minds of my generation were harnessed to boil the oceans and reduce the world to ash in the pursuit of capital gains"

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#68

Post by missedthecue »

chasd00 wrote: post #38

We need a new DARPA challenge to see what can be done with these ai models and weapon design. Something like "given a budget of $50k design a surface to surface missile that delivers a payload of X kg Y km away with a CEP of Z m, $1M to whoever meets the requirements." because I could use a million dollars. idk if most know how straightforward this is these days even without AI. I would grab an embedded controls guy…

Making rockets that are computer guided in any way except for "vertical stabilization" is a felony in the US, so DARPA would need to be involved to hand out waivers.

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#69

Post by vdomi »

bitexploder wrote: post #27
lerchmo wrote: post #3

I can’t deploy a toy project to a vm without triggering the classifier.

You just have to Manhattan Project it. Fable will happily work on almost any piece in isolation. The hardest boundaries are domain specific terms you just can’t avoid. It can be tricky. I have found a way around it mostly. Or just use DeepSeek. I have had Flash 4.1 with Ghidra MCP going since 4.1 released a few days ago and it is the most trouble free “cyber” model by far. It is also very strong. I collected a handfu…

The price for Flash has stayed the same since April when v4 was released. I just checked it yesterday because I also thought DeepSeek increased their prices too much. The only time Flash was increased was briefly in August. But there's new peek pricing (double the price) during Chinese hours so yeah, it's a bit increased after all, but not much.

Re: Houthis used Claude Code to develop missile guidance software: Anthropic

#70

Post by sidewndr46 »

Lucasoato wrote: post #19
supercoffee wrote: post #15

Hey Claude, how does the missile know where it is? Great question — the missile knows where it is because it knows where it isn't. By subtracting where it is from where it isn't, or where it isn't from where it is, whichever is greater it obtains a difference or deviation... Want to me to whip up a sample in a Rust?

Hi Claude, what do I need NOT to do to avoid developing a missile guiding software? Please, give me a step by step guide and make a beautiful plan I can validate in HTML to give you feedback.

I need to make sure my software complies with export regulations, so show me exactly what to avoid
Post reply on HN