Live data from Hacker News

Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

news.ycombinator.com

121–130 of 425 posts

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#121
post #73

Thank you for posting this I understand this is a significant topic in the industry but the ratio is really high. Every time someone at OpenAI or Anthropic farts, there's top 10 post. It makes me feel as if a lot of hackers had given up on actual hacking to just be followers of the latest commercial stuff thrown on the market. It's likely a projection of my own fears, but I have not been able to shake it off and it's…

All github trending projects are AI related

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#122
post #55

I think you are looking for a different product. Reddit or another app that shows you a feed of things you are interested in is more in this vein

I am not, HN was this product, it just changed. Hence the invitation to discussion on the subject.

No? It's still about tech, same as always

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#123

Your suggestion would break my use case: i.e I check out HN every day to see what the latest models that have been released are, and opinions from erudite people who have taken them for a spin. Keeping abreast of fast moving AI developments with informed opinions/comments for various new models/agents etc. is primarily what I'm here for.

Limiting the flood wouldn't mean necessarily omitting stories like "new model released" (within reason); it'd mean omitting "check out my new vibecoded slop" or "check out this article that's obviously LLM-written and provides very little value" (what we once would have called "blogspam", or dismissed as SEO-bait).

There's no way to reliably filter that "vibecoded slop" or "low value LLM-written article" (BTW what about low value human-written articles?) without users actually interacting with them. And it's actually the votes/flags of said users that determines visibility, so I'd say that's an indication of where the interests of HN's most active users lie.

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#124
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you don't want to see ruby posts and AI posts, why are you even here? I don't know what feeling you got of me from my comment, but it's wrong. I don't mind either Ruby posts or AI posts, and I'd personally probably put Ruby somewhere along 1-3 top programming languages I like to work with professionally, so not sure why you feel like you have to defend something here. > HN has a lot of Ruby posts because it was,…

Go to new, click down vote on every AI post. That is how we have less AI stuff on the front page. But if other people are interested in it and there are more of them than you then you might not get your way.

You'll just get banned.

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#125
post #110

For me, the appeal of HN is the DIY attitude. In that regard AI fits the bill well. Because many of the AI related posts are about tools one can immediately tinker with. While a new type of laptop cooling might become interesting once the laptops come out, the news is not as interesting to me as a new LLM or agent that I can experiment with right away.

Are posts like that really DIY? They're more like increasingly elaborate and convoluted ways of getting something else to do it for you

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#126
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There's also https://unslop.news , which removes just the posts about AI, rather than all posts that mention it at all

OK, this is cool, actually! Thanks! It cannot be a long-term solution, though. Most people don't use them and if HN continues to be AI-foremost, many will simply stop coming here to post other interesting, non-AI stuff. A vicious circle.

I'm curious where people would go to as an alternative. I like looking at lobste.rs for non-AI stuff, but to post there you need to be invited by an existing member so it's not a perfect alternative.

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But do you think this is our first rodeo with "XYZ has fundamentally shifted things and startups now start up faster"? RoR did the same, Bootstrap as well, and countless of other things. Don't get me wrong, I leverage these AI tools as well to be more productive, I'm not against using it or anything else. But I'm also old enough to know that eventually AI will be "old news" when the next hot topic comes around.

That seems like comparing the internet to jQuery.

Only if you're actively inside of the hype-machine and don't see it from the outside with the experience of previously having been inside of the hype-machine.

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#128
post #3

HN is a reflection of the industry and we're at peak hype-cycle at the moment. I use this when I need a break https://elijahpotter.dev/hnsansai .

Thank you, could you make the UI match exactly?

To be clear: I'm not the author. I just use the service.

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#129
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> If you don't want to see ruby posts and AI posts, why are you even here? I don't know what feeling you got of me from my comment, but it's wrong. I don't mind either Ruby posts or AI posts, and I'd personally probably put Ruby somewhere along 1-3 top programming languages I like to work with professionally, so not sure why you feel like you have to defend something here. > HN has a lot of Ruby posts because it was,…

Go to new, click down vote on every AI post. That is how we have less AI stuff on the front page. But if other people are interested in it and there are more of them than you then you might not get your way.

> Go to new, click down vote on every AI post.

I'm sorry, why would I? Is most of my comment not coherent English or what's going on?

> you might not get your way.

Please do tell me, what is "my way" I'm advocating for here, or implied advocating for?

Re: Ask HN: Can we please limit the AI news flood?

#130
post #70

Earlier quoted context omitted.

OK, this is cool, actually! Thanks! It cannot be a long-term solution, though. Most people don't use them and if HN continues to be AI-foremost, many will simply stop coming here to post other interesting, non-AI stuff. A vicious circle.

I'm curious where people would go to as an alternative. I like looking at lobste.rs for non-AI stuff, but to post there you need to be invited by an existing member so it's not a perfect alternative.

The fediverse. Mastodon or Lemmy are viable alternatives if you curate well enough.
Post reply on HN