Live data from Hacker News

Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

the-independent.com

81–90 of 112 posts

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#81
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not disclosing how much they were paid... I see that as incredibly dishonest and scummy. Sure "an opportunity regarding the trademark" yadda yadda... empty lawyerspeak that turns me right away.

Why? What business is it of yours? They were probably under an agreement not to reveal the buyer or amount. Meta in turn probably wouldn’t have wanted news to get out and people forerunning them to claim other online properties just to sell them back.

> They were probably under an agreement not to reveal the buyer or amount.

I guess they could've, I dunno, said so then?

Now that, obviously, everyone knows what happened...

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#82

Wild so many creators are pouring their life’s work into these platforms instead of their personal website

If you're a band, your life's work is the music. The platform is just a communication channel.

Their website can provide the backbone for concerts, merch, DTC tix maybe? I’m sure the fans that are not on these platforms would appreciate.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#83
post #76

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. The name changed happened across platforms including Twitter\X. Meta doesn’t own X. Is nobody reading the article? This comment section is crazy.

This place has become Reddit with how easy it is to farm upvotes for any “evil corpos” take, no matter how clueless or inane.

> This place has become Reddit […]

Not reading TFA (the fine article) has been a noble Internet tradition since (at least) the earliest days of Slashdot.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#84

> The exact circumstances surrounding the changes aren't clear. The exact circumstances are that they likely paid them a shitload of money.

Don't be so generous in your assumptions. Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. Or if they were lucky, maybe the band got a few Meta branded t-shirts, as was the case for one of the other victims from the article. Seriously, look at that list of all the times Meta stole people's handles. Why would this time be any different?

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49636930

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#86

Wild so many creators are pouring their life’s work into these platforms instead of their personal website

network effect.

Interoperability that POSSE and ATPROTO provide will free us from the network effect. You know what saves us from the network effect? Interoperability.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Don't be so generous in your assumptions. Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. Or if they were lucky, maybe the band got a few Meta branded t-shirts, as was the case for one of the other victims from the article. Seriously, look at that list of all the times Meta stole people's handles. Why would this time be any different?

> Meta simply stole the username because they could, and gave the old owner nothing in return. The name changed happened across platforms including Twitter\X. Meta doesn’t own X. Is nobody reading the article? This comment section is crazy.

That's what happens when you abuse people's trust for years: they don't trust you.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#88
post #46

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Well in a decent society you can't take things that aren't yours. Nobody using Muse the tool knows or gives a fuck who Muse the band is, the band itself is twice their age. At 32 years a band is reaching Spinal Tap stage and they could probably use the cash. Occam's razor and all that.

Talk about sour grapes. Muse remains ridiculously popular and I will bet my bank account that there are more Muse fans than slop enthusiasts.

The irony of a highly talented band that have been actually doing the work for over twenty years being pushed aside to make room for Meta's model that promises you won't have to actually do the work.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#89
post #44
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When a company is known for being malicious by default, to the point of knowingly covering up their ongoing and extensive contributions to teen suicides, it is not unreasonable for people to expect they would steal social media accounts to suit their interests. They are pure unadulterated evil. They are guilty until proven innocent at this point.

I disagree, this is an unreasonable and almost certainly incorrect thing to assume happened in this case. The fact that one hates XYZ is not a good reason to turn one's brain off and lose the ability to think rationally about XYZ. In fact, I would argue that there's never a good reason to turn one's brain off and lose the ability to think even moderately intelligently.

I am agreeing it is unlikely it was actually malicious, but it is Meta and they deserve no charity. If it is even a small possibility they did the evil thing, we should all operate on the assumption they did the evil thing anyway until proven innocent.

I hope all the non charitable assumptions they deserve snowball enough to hurt them.

May their stock price burn in hell.

Re: Rock band Muse lose social media handles to Meta’s new AI tool

#90
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When a company is known for being malicious by default, to the point of knowingly covering up their ongoing and extensive contributions to teen suicides, it is not unreasonable for people to expect they would steal social media accounts to suit their interests. They are pure unadulterated evil. They are guilty until proven innocent at this point.

That’s not how either logic or justice work.

[deleted]
Post reply on HN