Live data from Hacker News

Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

techemails.com

211–220 of 299 posts

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#211

Just last week, I was trying to sign up to Microsoft.com and got stuck in the captcha step. They have famously dysfunctional captcha system, people can't sign up to Microsoft and complain a lot about it online, and yet, it's not fixed. Microsoft always built dysfunctional software. They were never good at this. Hotmail was an unusable product, it was so painful to use it and Gmail took over the entire market in a yea…

> Hotmail was an unusable product, it was so painful to use it and Gmail took over the entire market in a year. Nobody ever said: "oh, I miss X about Hotmail"

Hotmail was a 1997 acquisition:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Outlook.com#Launch_of_Hotmail

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#212
post #38

Can someone in Microsoft confirm my suspicion that this thread is still going and nothing was fixed?

MovieMaker was discontinued in 2017 and replaced by ClipChamp. MS acquired ClipChamp and it was integrated into windows in 2022. So basically closed, will not fix.

I know people rag on Windows programs a lot, but ClipChamp is the worst, most bloated piece of software I have ever used in my life. It's so confusing how bad it is. I wish we still had movie maker, earnestly.

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#213

This is a good and bit surprising one. I have a hard time believing the CEO of Palantir has this many generational points I agree with, Zuck too, but I do. https://www.techemails.com/p/mark-zuckerberg-peter-thiel-mil...

Zuck:

> While our company has a special role in the lives of this generation, this is likely particularly important for how I show up because I am the most well-known person of my generation.

My god these people… I didn’t even know you could be that self-absorbed. It’s jarring.

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#214
post #213

This is a good and bit surprising one. I have a hard time believing the CEO of Palantir has this many generational points I agree with, Zuck too, but I do. https://www.techemails.com/p/mark-zuckerberg-peter-thiel-mil...

Zuck: > While our company has a special role in the lives of this generation, this is likely particularly important for how I show up because I am the most well-known person of my generation. My god these people… I didn’t even know you could be that self-absorbed. It’s jarring.

Ok, but please don't post unsubstantive comments to HN. We're trying for something different here.

(and particularly not unsubstantive+indignant ones, which are the worst for the kind of discussion we're trying for)

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#215

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's very common. From a certain level up, execs rarely use the products they are responsible for. It's all about strategy, committees, meetings, plans and reports. For them the product is just an abstract thing. When I rented a Buick car, I thought to myself that there is no way any decision maker ever tried the car and thought that this is ok. I think one of the strengths of Apple during the Jobs days was that Jobs…

> When I look at the blatant bugs MacOS and iOS had in the last years, I also think that the current Apple big shots never use their stuff or they would have noticed. The crazy thing is that it's more likely that most people in Apple are using their own products, versus any of the Android phone manufacturers or within Google, where it's likely a few of them would be using the Apple ecosystem instead. Many of them are…

One thing that drives me nuts for example is the indicator for remaining disk space. I have this icon on my desktop that says "Macintosh HD | 995 GB, 273 GB free". This used to work great until a few years ago. Copy 1 GB onto the disk and it displays 1 GB less free disk space.

But since a few years it goes up and down daily by 100 GB or more. Sometimes I have 350 GB, sometimes I have 100 GB. I think it has to do with Time Machine snapshots and purgeable space (whatever that means) but it's totally useless now. I can't tell for sure if I can copy 250 GB to my disk or not. It may fail now but work 2 hours later. How come nobody notices such a fundamental thing not working? Somehow the dogfooding doesn't seem to work. Or maybe the Apple people all have 8 TB disks so they don't care.

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#216

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is unfortunately par for the course at many big companies. I have re-lived this exact same thread so many times I've lost count 1. Leader escalates issue to his team 2. The team scrambles to come up with a solution 3. No one wants to take ownership. #NotMyProblem 4. weeks or months are spent on 'developing a plan' 5. nothinghappens.jpg

The Soviet Union didn't fall, it got merged into Microsoft

Capitalism at its finest! Or wait, never mind

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#217

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Most of the thread is lower level staff specifically trying to address the raised issues. We have no idea what conversations this triggered among the exec team about the broader strategic issues Bill raised.

Those are all Executives. It's actually funny that you're thinking they are 'lower level staff' because that's how it seems by their reaction, but those are literally top Execs. That's really how these orgs often work. 'Dear Leader Is Angry' will set the whole org into a tizzy. I've seen this countless times - 'XXX said it', and the littlest thing will get moved. Often - this is good, it means the org is responsive t…

Lower level than the former CEO And President of the board.

The point is this was not a round robin reply all buckpassing exercise with BillG and the senior corporate leaders still on the reply list. This is a specific downstream chain of email.

I’m not sure I understand what people here think the right thing to do is when the company founder emails a bunch of senior execs telling them they seem to have let things all go to crap.

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#218
post #188

My favorite bit about this is how none of the execs want to take ownership of the change, but instead trying to put someone else in the hot seat and/or start a Committee. This feels like an email that should have been blasted to the entire company. Top-down, empower employees to think of a more unified experience. Then again, all of the external jokes about Microsoft indicate that every department is fighting for the…

> every department is fighting for their lives against the others https://bonkersworld.net/img/2011-06-27_organizational_chart...

I love how Google looks like an MLP. I suspect their leadership would agree with that portrayal. You can imagine the activation functions: "Will this get me promoted?" "Will this get us bad press?"

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#219

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I have seen that too many times too in big companies, but I wouldn't say that it results in nothinghappens.jpg It results in the equivalent of treating an infection with Tylenol rather than antibiotics. The exact symptom reported by a "Leader" will usually get fixed, but in a more of a "KPI hacking" rather than a fundamental fix to the problem. I have seen a "Leader" point to the staggering number of support tickets…

The more interesting question is why would so many thousands of people in a big firm seemingly be fine with frustrating customers and giving the appearance of a gaggle of clowns? Standard psychology says they should be highly sensitive to status loss, but it almost seems the opposite.

Ask anyone at a FAANG and they will tell you that large corporations get flak every day for a lot of things, some justified and some unjustified. As an IC, you need to tune it all out and let the people whose full time job is to deal with that sort of thing handle it.

Re: Bill Gates tries to install MovieMaker (2003)

#220
post #38

Earlier quoted context omitted.

MovieMaker was discontinued in 2017 and replaced by ClipChamp. MS acquired ClipChamp and it was integrated into windows in 2022. So basically closed, will not fix.

I know people rag on Windows programs a lot, but ClipChamp is the worst, most bloated piece of software I have ever used in my life. It's so confusing how bad it is. I wish we still had movie maker, earnestly.

My favorite thing is how it takes 34 seconds to initialize, every time you open it, for no particular reason.
Post reply on HN