Live data from Hacker News

Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

lax-skyline.parcelscope.net

31–40 of 186 posts

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#31
post #27
post #19

They paved paradise, and put up a parking lot.

Paradise? LA was a big giant horrible underdeveloped wasteland in Spanish/Mexican times which, at the time in 1849, had 1,600 residents. Most of them had a largely pastoral life and life was brutal there. LA under US rule is the prime example of what industrialized people can do to a place that lacked nearly everything of what it is at this moment: a world-class city. Objectively, if it had stayed under Mexican rule,…

Funny. It's concrete hell.

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#32

It's amazing how little has changed in recent years in LA. The massive downzoning of the 1980s had its effect: prevent efficient land use, and channel money into the hands of landlords and homeowners from all newcomers. LA is a ridiculously unaffordable place to live, not because it's nice, but because of an artificial shortage of built space, due to a monopoly on the permission to build.

And don’t forget prop 13, there’s negative incentive for property to change hands and develop.

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#33
post #5

[flagged]

This started as a data puzzle. There is a lot of public data but it's hosted by for-profit companies and the data models don't seem to be coherent (probably lots of good reasons for the data models being the way they are, so no criticism, and it's wonderful they are public.) So for LA City, they use Socrata (owned by Tyler Technologies -- NYSE: TYL) to host and publish open data. LA City also uses Esri's ArcGIS for g…

It’s great! Agreed don’t feed the trolls.

I’ve helped with a few other zoning visualization projects recently, similar workflow. The only similarity is that each city/jurisdiction makes its data available in a different way. It’s usually accessible but it does mean there’s a lot of work munging the data to a usable format.

Here’s one of the projects: https://github.com/kfarr/zoningviz

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#34
This is more like the construction date of buildings that have survived. Some early neighborhoods (like palms) have been completely replaced building by building so they really appear as dark here when they weren't. It had a downtown in the 1890s but all those buildings are gone. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Palms,_Los_Angeles#/media/File...

it's basically this data: https://portal.assessor.lacounty.gov/ through this portal https://data.lacity.org/

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#36
post #33

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This started as a data puzzle. There is a lot of public data but it's hosted by for-profit companies and the data models don't seem to be coherent (probably lots of good reasons for the data models being the way they are, so no criticism, and it's wonderful they are public.) So for LA City, they use Socrata (owned by Tyler Technologies -- NYSE: TYL) to host and publish open data. LA City also uses Esri's ArcGIS for g…

It’s great! Agreed don’t feed the trolls. I’ve helped with a few other zoning visualization projects recently, similar workflow. The only similarity is that each city/jurisdiction makes its data available in a different way. It’s usually accessible but it does mean there’s a lot of work munging the data to a usable format. Here’s one of the projects: https://github.com/kfarr/zoningviz

Yes, this is incredibly similar to the pipeline I ended up with -- https://github.com/kfarr/zoningviz/blob/main/HOW_IT_WORKS.md

The other thing I learned is that some of the data sets use a destructive insert, so unless someone is doing a data snapshot data elements can be lost. (The vendors charge extra time-series option.)

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#38
post #30

A complementary view of one point in time is the LA Noire video game's attempt to recreate a (condensed and simplified) 1940s LA environment, with 3D architecture, cars, and ongoing expansion. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OGPh2AcmG2A The storytelling atmosphere is somber film-noire-ish, but there's simultaneously a feeling of national prosperity and potential for many (with notable unjust exceptions), like I think…

Did not think of that - yes that is a really interesting idea. Totally different way with interacting with data. I'm going to ponder that...

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#39
post #27
post #19

They paved paradise, and put up a parking lot.

Paradise? LA was a big giant horrible underdeveloped wasteland in Spanish/Mexican times which, at the time in 1849, had 1,600 residents. Most of them had a largely pastoral life and life was brutal there. LA under US rule is the prime example of what industrialized people can do to a place that lacked nearly everything of what it is at this moment: a world-class city. Objectively, if it had stayed under Mexican rule,…

One's "underdeveloped wasteland" is someone else's untouched paradise. Particularly someone like Joni Mitchell.

Re: Watch Los Angeles get built, one building at a time (1880–2026)

#40
post #19

They paved paradise, and put up a parking lot.

Is there an alternative if 13 million people want to live somewhere?

Somewhat sadly, the reason a lot of the ancestors of those 13 millions moved there was that they wanted an unpaved paradise.

Unfortunately, humans do not know restraint.

Post reply on HN