Live data from Hacker News

Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

uniklinik-freiburg.de

11–20 of 55 posts

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had to stop after 6 months because my testosterone dropped so much (serious, blood test confirmed). Felt way better for the first few months, then slowly lower energy and not like myself. Eventually realized more vegetables is good, but nailing is protein wise on true vegan diet is very very hard.

I am vegan except for fish, and find it works really well. Sardines are awesome!

A good term for that is pescatarian - as eating fish is neither vegan nor veg!

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#12
post #2

Living to 100 is overrated anyways. As if this planet will even be worth living on if climate change continues to go unchecked. Or if humanity will even exist after the inevitable mass extinction event

always some excuse to keep eating meat

None needed.

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#13

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I had to stop after 6 months because my testosterone dropped so much (serious, blood test confirmed). Felt way better for the first few months, then slowly lower energy and not like myself. Eventually realized more vegetables is good, but nailing is protein wise on true vegan diet is very very hard.

I am vegan except for fish, and find it works really well. Sardines are awesome!

So not vegan at all.

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#14
Both pure vegan and pure meat camps claim to have scientific evidence that it works, which make me question if change is what the body responds to. From personal experience, eating less often and fasting does seem to improve things like brain fog, indigestion etc.

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#17

We need to collectively evolve as a species past intensive industrial animal confinement. To think, we can be more compassionate and don't need to sacrifice our health, and may in fact be able to live healthier!

[dead]

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#18
> the participants were randomly assigned to two groups: 24 followed a vegan diet for four weeks, while 24 followed a diet particularly high in meat.

This may be correct technique for a small-n, short-duration study.

But don't expect the results to be applicable to typical non-vegans.

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#19

Reminds me that I need to study the impacts of a vegan diet in the science literature to understand how aggressively I should be pursuing it. The times I’ve lived on a near vegan diet, I feel quietly better in lots of little unexpected ways. Happy to chase books or links if people have them lying around.

I had to stop after 6 months because my testosterone dropped so much (serious, blood test confirmed). Felt way better for the first few months, then slowly lower energy and not like myself. Eventually realized more vegetables is good, but nailing is protein wise on true vegan diet is very very hard.

Correlation is not causation, especially in a sample of 1, the plural of anecdote is not data etc etc. Protein is easy, just eat some beans and rice, tofu, tempeh etc. You can't just take the diet you had before and subtract things and expect it to work, you have to substitute. Make sure to get B12, D and maybe omega 3 and creatine either as supplements or fortified in foods, and get your levels checked every year or so.

I've been vegan for 15+ years, and I'm willing to say there are zero health benefits over a healthy omnivorous diet. The people who find one are misattributing it. It's not that vegan is healthier, just that what they were doing before was decidedly unhealthy. For a lot of people going vegan is the first time they actually think about what they eat, read labels etc, which is where most of the benefit comes from.

Re: Four Weeks of a Vegan Diet Alter Signs of Inflammation and Aging

#20

Reminds me that I need to study the impacts of a vegan diet in the science literature to understand how aggressively I should be pursuing it. The times I’ve lived on a near vegan diet, I feel quietly better in lots of little unexpected ways. Happy to chase books or links if people have them lying around.

I had to stop after 6 months because my testosterone dropped so much (serious, blood test confirmed). Felt way better for the first few months, then slowly lower energy and not like myself. Eventually realized more vegetables is good, but nailing is protein wise on true vegan diet is very very hard.

It is absolutely not "very hard." It is challenging at first because like anything else, the startup costs of new habit formation can be high. But tofu, soy milk, seitan, tempeh, lentils, and many other plant protein sources are highly available and easy to cook with once you try. Been at it for a few years myself and at this point, it's extremely easy. I take protein shakes when working out, just like I did when I ate animal products.

Everyone is different, but if you weren't actually able to hit protein macros then I think that's a skill that isn't too hard to improve for most people (if they have a decent reason for wanting to go vegan in the first place).

Post reply on HN