Live data from Hacker News

Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search

productrise.app

81–87 of 87 posts

Re: Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search

#81

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are very strict protections in place surrounding software’s use of a users address info. It’s not just a library call to access it (which the Shopping UI might do). Requires explicit user opt in on a per feature basis.

Is that GDPR? Is it still true in America?

There are internal controls as to the use of personal data within Google. Contrary to the popular opinion, personal data is not actually a free for all within Google

Re: Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search

#83
post #32

They’re using “traditional search” to mean the shopping specific search widget or page, which is a separate feature from traditional search. It aggregates retailer listings and sorts them by price. The AI mode is based on normal top search results, which are oriented toward information about the product like the manufacturer’s page, which is usually going to be full MSRP. So technically correct that the AI mode is no…

It's not a trick. What you receive as shipping or taxes on google shopping are not the final ones, google doesn't have your full address, neither doesn't have info from the merchant for all taxes (depends on the country) and shipping applied to the product to all possible locations.

It’s obviously a trick.

Re: Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search

#84
post #40
post #17

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The general implication is the opposite effect. The corporation wants to make more money. They make larger margins with this of course. But beyond that, the implication is that whatever sales are lost from the more expensive price are simply made up otherwise. If products are 20% more expensive but this only results in 10-15% less sales, the corporation is still very happy, particularly due to the margin bit. If loss…

I think the 10-15% hypothetical reduction in sales is their point, not the effect on corporate profits. Less consumer junk for the landfill is good.

Exactly.

Re: Google AI Mode shows same products 21.6% more expensive than traditional search

#87
post #68

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On eBay for certain scammy sellers, but not as a general rule. And on Amazon, certainly not for items sold by Amazon or part of Prime. Again, only scammy third-party sellers.

I guess by definition if they’re doing such things they’re scammy… and aren’t 3rd party sellers the biggest contingent of sellers on Amazon? I mean, I found such listings for almost all of the things I recently shopped for, including water bottles, cooking appliances, sports shorts, coffee cups, camping chairs, usb drives, video cables, beach sandals, winter wear, multivitamin supplements… Not quite a scientific stud…

I buy a lot of stuff on Amazon, and 99.9% of it has free shipping. I've had to pay a shipping fee maybe 3 times over the past decade, if I'm guessing?

Even if there are tons of scammy expensive-shipping listings, if people are almost never buying them and they almost never get surfaced in search results, it doesn't matter.

But I've also never even tried sorting by cheapest, because default sorting by relevance has always worked for me.

Post reply on HN