Live data from Hacker News

Mamdani bans AI in NYC schools

nytimes.com

11–20 of 176 posts

Re: Mamdani bans AI in NYC schools

#11
Here's another (non-paywalled) source for this news: https://abcnews.com/Technology/new-york-city-public-schools-...

The ban goes through eighth grade, and in high school apparently there's a specific AI literacy class. It's unclear from the article if that's the only AI in high school or it's just unregulated.

My opinion: it's a good policy and frankly just common sense.

- Students using AI risk offloading their cognition onto the AI and thereby skipping the actual learning process.

- Teachers using AI likewise do a disservice to the students.

In the middle of all that, there may actually be a version of AI that can help people learn without incurring the major downsides, but I've not seen any evidence of that in the current AI systems, to the point that an outright ban in the school setting makes sense. I'm heartened to see more education organizations think similarly [1].

[1]: https://www.law.berkeley.edu/academics/registrar/academic-ru...

Re: Mamdani bans AI in NYC schools

#17
post #5

This makes about as much sense to me as banning all personal computers in the eighties from schools. You are putting these kids at a decided disadvantage.

[flagged]

Current chatbots are better tutors than an average school teacher imho.

Not saying that we should replace ones with the other ones, but I’d say from age 11-12 and up kids should be taught how to use AI well.

Post reply on HN