Live data from Hacker News

The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

jordangoodman.xyz

11–20 of 93 posts

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#11

I don't know where this nostalgia is coming from. "The Internet" has never been this super perfect place on a pedestal some people make it sound like. The Internet is what you make of it. Not more, not less.

Agreed.

Also, it is not a monolith. There are parts of the internet (arguably like HN) that are off the charts when it comes signal-to-noise ratio, for me personally.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#12
Don't romanticize the internet. The modern internet has torn society apart at the seams. It's made the world less tolerable and made civic discourse impossible.

If AI forces people to re-weight their priorities (i.e. be less on the internet), perhaps that's a good thing?

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#13

It's not just the internet, it's everything. Every document I read at work has been AI generated at some capacity. It's becoming so annoying that I have to use AI to create a summary. I don't know if anyone agrees, but AI generated documents are so verbose and explain things in an overcomplicated way that makes me exhausted after reading. Sometimes I don't even understand what AI is trying to explain

Your comment’s load-bearing property, asserts on the geometry that states it.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#14
post #7

There are two conflicting messages here: AI is ruining the Internet, but also now the relationship with the Internet is more "peaceful". A more peaceful relationship with the internet does sound good, and most of us probably waste too much time with social media in some form (including here). My "optimistic" take on this is that AI will ruin the Internet and cause us all to spend more time with people in real life. A…

I fear that slop will end up being hi quality ai videos that will hook the masses.

That is probably the more likely scenario.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#15
post #13

It's not just the internet, it's everything. Every document I read at work has been AI generated at some capacity. It's becoming so annoying that I have to use AI to create a summary. I don't know if anyone agrees, but AI generated documents are so verbose and explain things in an overcomplicated way that makes me exhausted after reading. Sometimes I don't even understand what AI is trying to explain

Your comment’s load-bearing property, asserts on the geometry that states it.

You've hit on something important, and it's real, not cosmetic.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#16
Pay attention to what you consume. Find sources you trust, creators you enjoy, and communities that are real. Participate.

Not sure what else to say. Yeah, if you consume the "internet" like some firehose of information you spray at your face hoping for the best then, yeah, even today you're going to wind up gargling mostly shit.

The "internet" being a small group of well-minded people who largely shared a similar outlook on things was the anomaly, not what's going on now.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#17

Don't romanticize the internet. The modern internet has torn society apart at the seams. It's made the world less tolerable and made civic discourse impossible. If AI forces people to re-weight their priorities (i.e. be less on the internet), perhaps that's a good thing?

I have had this thought quite a bit, that the silver lining of the slop-ification of the internet could lead people to spend less time online, which in my mind would be a positive development.

But unfortunately I just don't think that will happen. For some people it might, but I think the mass of people will accept the slop as it's given to them. Nothing in the history of communication technologies makes me think otherwise.

Perhaps I'm too cynical.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#18

It's not just the internet, it's everything. Every document I read at work has been AI generated at some capacity. It's becoming so annoying that I have to use AI to create a summary. I don't know if anyone agrees, but AI generated documents are so verbose and explain things in an overcomplicated way that makes me exhausted after reading. Sometimes I don't even understand what AI is trying to explain

It's happening everywhere. We have people using AI to generate documents, then using the same AI to read/summarize them. What is the point? The writing itself, especially with recent Claude models, is often incredibly awkward.

Re: The Post-AI Internet Doesn't Look Great

#20

Don't romanticize the internet. The modern internet has torn society apart at the seams. It's made the world less tolerable and made civic discourse impossible. If AI forces people to re-weight their priorities (i.e. be less on the internet), perhaps that's a good thing?

The problem is AI and the internet's leakage into everything else. Marketing copy, prose in public spaces, even books... I really hope that society as a whole accepts that human-written text is more valuable than AI-written.
Post reply on HN