Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

hnmatchmaker.com

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

31–40 of 55 posts

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#31

Post by nrmitchi »

dvt wrote: post #29
nrmitchi wrote: post #4

> If you've submitted a post to this month's 'Who Wants to Be Hired?", you can find your matching job listings at https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/:user_name , for example https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/G4Vi I'm sure you mean well but as someone who has considered posting on who wants to be hired in the past.... this is creepy AF and feels like a giant invasion of privacy. If you did it privately , or authenticated peopl…

> this is creepy AF and feels like a giant invasion of privacy People have been building HN job listing scrapers for years. Heck, I built one over a decade ago[1] (though it's offline now). This is a very common "Show HN:" project, and the argument that it's somehow bad faith and creepy is just absolutely nuts when posting on a public forum, specifically to get more exposure. [1] https://github.com/dvx/hackjob

That's not what this is though. This is not (just) scraping job postings; the public-facing interface of this is "Greg, who I don't know, wants a job. Here are the jobs that I think would be good for Greg, who again, I don't know".

My claim of "bad faith" was specifically because the post, between 1) explicitly pointing to a "full stack ai dev platform" ("So I had abacus.ai whip one up"), and 2) the entire missing list of "observations" (mid post), came off more as a shadow advertisement for an ai dev tool than an actual project.

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#32

Post by dvt »

nrmitchi wrote: post #31
dvt wrote: post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> this is creepy AF and feels like a giant invasion of privacy People have been building HN job listing scrapers for years. Heck, I built one over a decade ago[1] (though it's offline now). This is a very common "Show HN:" project, and the argument that it's somehow bad faith and creepy is just absolutely nuts when posting on a public forum, specifically to get more exposure. [1] https://github.com/dvx/hackjob

That's not what this is though. This is not (just) scraping job postings; the public-facing interface of this is "Greg, who I don't know, wants a job. Here are the jobs that I think would be good for Greg, who again, I don't know". My claim of "bad faith" was specifically because the post, between 1) explicitly pointing to a "full stack ai dev platform" ("So I had abacus.ai whip one up"), and 2) the entire missing li…

I did the exact same thing[1] (minus the AI matching)—in fact, using the public HN firebase API, as you can see. So I fundamentally reject this premise. I had it running for years and no one complained and it scored me a few contracts because I also did a "Show HN:" and some folks liked it.

[1] https://github.com/dvx/hackjob/blob/master/assets/app/compon...

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#33

Post by SoftTalker »

all2 wrote: post #25
e12e wrote: post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It'll take two or three more of these before I've seen enough to start gelling the domain problems in my head. I don't understand - there's years of historical data to look at?

I suppose I could look backwards instead of forwards. Tbf, at this hour, it hadn't even occurred to me.

I wouldn't bother unless you just want to try to compile stats. The active job seekers and the open positions from more than a month ago probably aren't valid today.

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#34

Post by linkjuice4all »

LadyCailin wrote: post #8
usui wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The users in question are posting on a public forum under a username of their choosing, and it's still an invasion of privacy to read those posts and play pretend matchmaker?

I go out in public sometimes, but don’t want someone following me around live-streaming everything I do to twitch. Yes, it can be done in full view in public, and still be an invasion of privacy. why do you think they’re called glassholes and pervert glasses?

You hung up a “services offered” flyer on every town square around the world and want to control what people do with the information after you’ve shouted it into the void? Don’t post if you don’t want every tom, dick, or jAIne reading your stuff.

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#35

Post by joshribakoff »

probably_wrong wrote: post #12
usui wrote: post #7

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The users in question are posting on a public forum under a username of their choosing, and it's still an invasion of privacy to read those posts and play pretend matchmaker?

For starters, it breaks two rule of the thread: "Agencies, recruiters, job boards, and so on, are off topic here" and "please only email these addresses to discuss work opportunities". Not that you don't get spammed anyway, but still.

He didn’t post in the thread or email any candidate. He copied a public comment from one public site to another.

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#36

Post by nrmitchi »

dvt wrote: post #32
nrmitchi wrote: post #31

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's not what this is though. This is not (just) scraping job postings; the public-facing interface of this is "Greg, who I don't know, wants a job. Here are the jobs that I think would be good for Greg, who again, I don't know". My claim of "bad faith" was specifically because the post, between 1) explicitly pointing to a "full stack ai dev platform" ("So I had abacus.ai whip one up"), and 2) the entire missing li…

I did the exact same thing[1] (minus the AI matching)—in fact, using the public HN firebase API, as you can see. So I fundamentally reject this premise. I had it running for years and no one complained and it scored me a few contracts because I also did a "Show HN:" and some folks liked it. [1] https://github.com/dvx/hackjob/blob/master/assets/app/compon...

You seem to have ignored the second half of my response. In your case... you did it. This project, based on the current date, no data older than today, and the posters own statements, is "I asked gen-ai platform to make it for me, then pointed a domain at gen-ai-company hosting, and called it a thing I made."

As of the current moment, the domain is just pointing to an IP owned by "Abacus.AI, Inc.". The entire platform is "describe the app you want and we'll generate it and host it for you".

Might just be my opinion, but I consider a Show HN that is "look at the thing AI entirely made for me" to not really be aligned with good faith sharing of work/projects.

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#39

Post by Foobar8568 »

nrmitchi wrote: post #4

> If you've submitted a post to this month's 'Who Wants to Be Hired?", you can find your matching job listings at https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/:user_name , for example https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/G4Vi I'm sure you mean well but as someone who has considered posting on who wants to be hired in the past.... this is creepy AF and feels like a giant invasion of privacy. If you did it privately , or authenticated peopl…

I post once with a fake/hidden email address to be contacted. I received thousands of DocuSign emails...

Re: Show HN: HN Match Maker – Matching "Who Wants to Be Hired?" With "Who's Hiring?"

#40

Post by MrGilbert »

usui wrote: post #7
nrmitchi wrote: post #4

> If you've submitted a post to this month's 'Who Wants to Be Hired?", you can find your matching job listings at https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/:user_name , for example https://hnmatchmaker.com/user/G4Vi I'm sure you mean well but as someone who has considered posting on who wants to be hired in the past.... this is creepy AF and feels like a giant invasion of privacy. If you did it privately , or authenticated peopl…

The users in question are posting on a public forum under a username of their choosing, and it's still an invasion of privacy to read those posts and play pretend matchmaker?

   > The users in question are posting on a public forum under a username of their choosing, and it's still an invasion of privacy to read those posts and play pretend matchmaker?
Yes it is. There is an aggregation happening, that is not available on Hacker News per se. To make this aggregation easily available to anyone else is some kind of privacy invasion. To make matters worse, usernames can be traced back to IRL individuals, depending on the information they put into their "About" page on Hacker News. So yes, this is indeed an issue.
Post reply on HN