Live data from Hacker News

No AI Fridays

noaifridays.com

191–200 of 226 posts

Re: No AI Fridays

#191

Earlier quoted context omitted.

ADHD is an inability to focus. ChatGPT diagnosed you incorrectly.

Not even wrong: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/hyperfocus-and-adhd "When you have ADHD, the problem isn’t that you lack attention, it’s that you struggle to control your attention — to put your attention where you want it to go rather than having it go where it wants to go. Hyperfocus is a natural consequence of that lack of control." Lived it. Made it work for me professionally in the end. Do not not need pointy…

Sounds like it's just telling you what you want to hear. ADHD is when you can't focus, or when you focus too much. Really meaningful label then.

Re: No AI Fridays

#192

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The best engineers know how our systems work down to more levels, but for average developers producing average software with average impact, average output is acceptable. What if I told you the "best engineers" pretty much all know the same things? The tools they use at work and the code they write to get paid doesn't reflect even half of what they know. There will always be situations where a problem goes deep eno…

> What if I told you the "best engineers" pretty much all know the same things? I'd say that you need to provide some evidence for this extraordinary claim. > What if I told you that your "specialists", AI or not, are going to be objectively far worse at actually getting things done because they don't have the bigger picture in mind? I'd say that you need to provide some evidence for this extraordinary claim. > We've…

The "best engineers" we have right now started their careers when the startup era was hot and they now have 15-20+ years of experience. They wore all the hats while everyone else stunted themselves straight out of school by going to a big corporate office. In that era, the devs at a startup were the "everything people". I've met plenty of web app devs of that vintage who are just as comfortable compiling a linux kernel, setting up a k8s cluster, maintaining 2Us, etc. I've also met plenty of engineers who started out in the opposite direction, worked as app devs, and are now in high level architect or even CTO roles.

Anyone who chose to specialize went the vocational route of getting certifications and playing the contractor game. They have never truly handled anything on fire. They never stick around long enough to, and that's the whole point for them.

This pattern already happened in the (blue collar) "trades". It started in the late 20th century. Now we have some of the worst built homes, buildings, roads, etc. People will (sort of) put up with a pothole or leaky roof. They will not put up with major infrastructure outages or showstopper bugs that directly impact their minute-to-minute ability to function in modern society.

Do we really want to make this even worse with automated AI copypasta pretending to be "engineering"? Nobody is fooled. The cost cutting is hitting rock bottom, and tons of people overexposed to AI in their investments are about to lose their shirts.

Your "proof" is all there for anyone to find. Ask anyone outside your bubble.

Re: No AI Fridays

#193

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not even wrong: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/hyperfocus-and-adhd "When you have ADHD, the problem isn’t that you lack attention, it’s that you struggle to control your attention — to put your attention where you want it to go rather than having it go where it wants to go. Hyperfocus is a natural consequence of that lack of control." Lived it. Made it work for me professionally in the end. Do not not need pointy…

Sounds like it's just telling you what you want to hear. ADHD is when you can't focus, or when you focus too much. Really meaningful label then.

The Cleveland clinic is telling me what I want to hear? Righto squire.

Re: No AI Fridays

#194
Hard for me to take seriously a society addicted to destroying the planet through high tech hasn't already lost critical thinking and lives with high cognitive debt

Role playing we're all that smart while our economic behavior (I mean resource use not financial) suggests the opposite is really making me question the idea keeping electrical activity in the brain up is a sign of intelligence

Making life better for ourselves just going to make it worse for everyone eventually.

Having language to describe physics does not mean we control physics now. Entropy doesn't give a shit; we are its agents on Earth. Humans will destroy the structure of a human friendly environment. The only choice we have is 50-100 years or 1,000 based on how fast we consume it

Re: No AI Fridays

#195
post #190

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My zone is the big-picture zone. What are we building, what needs to be done, how do the interrelated bits all come together? I can tell an agent "go implement X" and start planning Y that comes after it. I don't really get in the zone for raw code typing, that's always been a slog.

I cannot imagine being able to plan the next thing when I don't know what issues the coding agent might run into with the previous/current task. It feels like a waste to be planning the next thing when my previous plan may turn out to be wrong. The only thing I can really think to do is to wait for the agent to be finished, which makes getting distracted by social media and other random stuff really easy. Total oppos…

I can't imagine free soloing El Capitan, but there's a guy out there doing it. My artistic skills cap out at shitty stick figures.

I get more distracted if I attempt to focus on just one thing for a day.

Different brains.

Re: No AI Fridays

#196

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not even wrong: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/hyperfocus-and-adhd "When you have ADHD, the problem isn’t that you lack attention, it’s that you struggle to control your attention — to put your attention where you want it to go rather than having it go where it wants to go. Hyperfocus is a natural consequence of that lack of control." Lived it. Made it work for me professionally in the end. Do not not need pointy…

Sounds like it's just telling you what you want to hear. ADHD is when you can't focus, or when you focus too much. Really meaningful label then.

As odd as it sounds this is correct. Hyper focus is a huge problem with ADHD. You forget to eat and get worse sleep because you're so focused on 1 problem.

This often means that you pay attention to nothing else around you or what's actually important which is where the deficit is.

Re: No AI Fridays

#197

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like it's just telling you what you want to hear. ADHD is when you can't focus, or when you focus too much. Really meaningful label then.

As odd as it sounds this is correct. Hyper focus is a huge problem with ADHD. You forget to eat and get worse sleep because you're so focused on 1 problem. This often means that you pay attention to nothing else around you or what's actually important which is where the deficit is.

Sounds like you're just defining ADHD to mean whatever you want it to mean. Thankfully we didn't have TikTok to diagnose hyperfocusers like Einstein with a brain disease, or we never would have got general relativity.

Re: No AI Fridays

#199

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As odd as it sounds this is correct. Hyper focus is a huge problem with ADHD. You forget to eat and get worse sleep because you're so focused on 1 problem. This often means that you pay attention to nothing else around you or what's actually important which is where the deficit is.

Sounds like you're just defining ADHD to mean whatever you want it to mean. Thankfully we didn't have TikTok to diagnose hyperfocusers like Einstein with a brain disease, or we never would have got general relativity.

I highly suggest you read about the subject. This isn't the fringe science you're implying. It's a big reason I was diagnosed by my doctor. And it's often treated quite well by taking ADHD medications.

  “While the estimated 8 million adults in the USA affected by attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) might find it nearly impossible to sit still in a lecture hall or excruciatingly challenging to focus on writing a term paper, these same individuals might find themselves spending hours at a time composing a new song, tinkering with their car, writing computer code, or watching television (Kessler et al., 2006). The term “hyperfocus” (HF) has been used to characterize this state of heightened, focused attention that individuals with ADHD frequently report (Brown, 2005; Conner, 1994; Ozel-Kizil et al., 2016).”[1]
[1]https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30267329/ Other reading: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/30267329/ https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12438511/

Re: No AI Fridays

#200

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Sounds like you're just defining ADHD to mean whatever you want it to mean. Thankfully we didn't have TikTok to diagnose hyperfocusers like Einstein with a brain disease, or we never would have got general relativity.

I highly suggest you read about the subject. This isn't the fringe science you're implying. It's a big reason I was diagnosed by my doctor. And it's often treated quite well by taking ADHD medications. “While the estimated 8 million adults in the USA affected by attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) might find it nearly impossible to sit still in a lecture hall or excruciatingly challenging to focus on writ…

Yes, the medicalization of normal human experiences is lamentable. But grant money doesn't appear without diseases for pharma to treat.
Post reply on HN