Live data from Hacker News

Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

cnn.com

21–30 of 62 posts

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#21

While they show Lake Ontario (Lake America) in the rest of the world, I would like to suggest that they apply a more patronizing treatment to the alias: Lake Ontario ("Lake America") The quotes add a certain.. je ne sais quoi. I think overall it's not Google's job to decide the names of things. Half of America voted for the circus, enjoy!

Well technically less than a quarter voted for it, but fair enough.

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#22
post #6

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The government doesn't get to name geographic features.

Who gets to name them?

Well Derry/Londonderry is officially called Londonderry, but Irish republicans didn't like the London link so call(ed) it Derry. So during the troubles it was a thing to refer to is as Derry/Londonderry.

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#24

While they show Lake Ontario (Lake America) in the rest of the world, I would like to suggest that they apply a more patronizing treatment to the alias: Lake Ontario ("Lake America") The quotes add a certain.. je ne sais quoi. I think overall it's not Google's job to decide the names of things. Half of America voted for the circus, enjoy!

[dead]

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#25

I think this is a great startup idea and unique opportunity - create Google Maps competitor on promise to have Lake Ontario and Gulf of Mexico named correctly, along with a promise to ignore other possible renamings in future. :)

We have MapQuest for this!

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#26

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This isn't really on Google. Countries disagree on how things should be named. Google sources the US centric view from the Geographic Names Information System (GNIS). Blame the person causing the GNIS updates.

Blame the person at Google who chose to source from GNIS, without edits.

It was a very reasonable decision when it was made around 2008.

Do you really expect a US based company to go to legal war with the US government over something like this? Because there would 100% be repercussions it they did.

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#27

Google is a perfect example of the banality of evil.

This isn't really on Google. Countries disagree on how things should be named. Google sources the US centric view from the Geographic Names Information System (GNIS). Blame the person causing the GNIS updates.

The person responsible for the GNIS corruption and the leadership of Google are in essence conjoined twins. The tech oligarchs are not going to make decisions based on interests that aren’t aligned directly with their personal enrichment; and the GNIS Corrupter-in-Chief wields such personal interests rather effectively.

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Blame the person at Google who chose to source from GNIS, without edits.

It was a very reasonable decision when it was made around 2008. Do you really expect a US based company to go to legal war with the US government over something like this? Because there would 100% be repercussions it they did.

Is there a legal requirement that non-governmental entities source their mapping data from official U.S. government sources?

Re: Google Maps changed to show Lake Ontario as Lake America

#30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was a very reasonable decision when it was made around 2008. Do you really expect a US based company to go to legal war with the US government over something like this? Because there would 100% be repercussions it they did.

Is there a legal requirement that non-governmental entities source their mapping data from official U.S. government sources?

I don't think that matters with the current administration.
Post reply on HN