Live data from Hacker News

Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

orbify.eu

181–190 of 199 posts

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#181
Nice demo, but can we talk about how this is patented. Should it be? Should something like this actually get granted.

While it's neat, it's neat on the order of a UX idea someone might just come up with at standup one day. Like, cool, worth an A/B test, but worth a patent? I don't think so.

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#182
post #23

First time I saw this idea was Berg's "Here and There" poster from 2009 (a year before Inception) though they acknowledge a bunch of earlier inspirations... https://berglondon.com/blog/2009/05/04/here-there-influences...

That seems like enough prior art to invalidate much of what could conceivably be considered novel in the pending patent...

Especially that it looks like to be an European patent and it is not clear what wouldn't be "software" in their patent.

But if it's not vibecoded landing page, they might also know that they have a dummy patent request that will probably be rejected but that probably in so many month that they can use the patent pending to get commercial and investment traction till then.

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#184
post #23

First time I saw this idea was Berg's "Here and There" poster from 2009 (a year before Inception) though they acknowledge a bunch of earlier inspirations... https://berglondon.com/blog/2009/05/04/here-there-influences...

That seems like enough prior art to invalidate much of what could conceivably be considered novel in the pending patent...

Playing devil's advocate: the projection alone won't be the patent and probably is not patentable on its own, the patent will be about applying such projections for real-time navigation which brings non-obvious difficulties that must be solved in a particular way (like the way the project is transformed during turns, how navigation is overlayed, and how motion sickness and distractions are counteracted) making the patent consist of the projection-styled navigation enabled by certain rules (what and how to present it) and the technical way the projections are transformed.

Having said that, the novelty is questionable since the projection is pretty well-known and creating a functional proof of concept that solves many of the patent's problems likely takes a day or so. But I'm not a lawyer so what do I know in this department?

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#185

Nice demo, but can we talk about how this is patented. Should it be? Should something like this actually get granted. While it's neat, it's neat on the order of a UX idea someone might just come up with at standup one day. Like, cool, worth an A/B test, but worth a patent? I don't think so.

I thought the same thing, just opened it and went "patent pending... Really?"

I am genuinely annoyed when someone gets a helpful UI idea and their immediate thought is "wow, I should patent this so I can monopolize this helpful idea".

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#186

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is exactly why on traditional gps maps I prefer it to be very very zoomed out. It's far too common that mapping tools make something like a sudden second turn invisible to you until it is too late to switch lanes.

I find that Apple Maps is typically pretty smart with its automatic zoom. For a typical intersection with just one turn to navigate, it will zoom in to give you a good sense of the lanes, stop signs/lights, etc. But when there are consecutive turns to navigate, or a heavily curved section of road (like highway on-ramps) it will zoom out and even rotate the map to show that upcoming context.

It's also pretty good about stacking up a second turn in the corner banner that shows your next maneuver

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#187

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Maps got really good at some point! I once pick it by accident for navigation, and never went back to Google Maps.

I've used it almost exclusively since around 2019, but that has been in the Bay Area and LA area where the data has presumably been very good relative to other areas.

A few years ago I saw Apple Maps get things wrong in Cupertino!

Re: Inception-style curved map for turn-by-turn directions

#190

I see a whole new business category being born: Nausea as a Service!

Yes, I'm not normally prone to motion sickness, but the change of perspective during a turn is quite unpleasant.

That surprised me too. VR is no issue for me, I can also usually stare at my phone in the car. But this site made me dizzy immediately.
Post reply on HN