Live data from Hacker News

“It works better in the app”

shkspr.mobi

21–30 of 496 posts

Re: “It works better in the app”

#22
post #9

At this point the barrier for me to install an app is pretty high. If you're going to needlessly gate certain functions behind an app that work on a desktop browser (or could work in-browser), then I just won't use those functions. If by extension that degrades the value I get from your site, then I just won't use the site, and I won't be contributing to ADU stats you promote to advertisers. Every single company has…

Indeed, I've no interest in native apps to do something that can be done in a web app and if you don't let me do it in a web app I'll bounce and either find someone who can or do without unless there is a seriously compelling use case (I'm not that dogmatic).

As a result the only native apps I use on my phone are Kindle, Authy and Firefox because I trust Firefox to prevent apps doing a lot of the sketchy shit locally a lot more than I trust an app/the host OS to do so.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#23
post #9

At this point the barrier for me to install an app is pretty high. If you're going to needlessly gate certain functions behind an app that work on a desktop browser (or could work in-browser), then I just won't use those functions. If by extension that degrades the value I get from your site, then I just won't use the site, and I won't be contributing to ADU stats you promote to advertisers. Every single company has…

I wish everyone thought like this. Unfortunately the average user demands an app and thinks they have nothing to hide.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#25

It's almost impossible to use social networks on mobile without installing their apps

I found that installing facebook dot com to my Home Screen on iOS works acceptably. Lets me check in on things every now and then and still be confident they’re very limited in what they can track.

Messenger doesn’t work but luckily I rarely if ever use it.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#26
post #21

It's almost impossible to use social networks on mobile without installing their apps

Didn't use to be. I stopped using facebook shortly after they blocked messenger on their webpage, so jokes on them I guess.

I wish Messenger had an auto-reply feature: "I probably won't see your message for a while because I don't install Meta apps on my phone"

Re: “It works better in the app”

#27

It's almost impossible to use social networks on mobile without installing their apps

When I got a new phone about a year ago, I decided that I wouldn't be installing any traditional social media apps (Tusky doesn't count) and that I'd use the web when "necessary". This has been a very successful experiment and resulted in me looking at Instagram _maybe_ once per week.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#28
post #9

At this point the barrier for me to install an app is pretty high. If you're going to needlessly gate certain functions behind an app that work on a desktop browser (or could work in-browser), then I just won't use those functions. If by extension that degrades the value I get from your site, then I just won't use the site, and I won't be contributing to ADU stats you promote to advertisers. Every single company has…

If your app is just a webpage that forces me to use an app just so you can spy on me I just won't use your product. I've switched brokers over it, I swapped banks, I stopped shopping at certain stores.

I'm done. The only say I have is in how I spend my money. Those companies won't get any of mine if I can help it.

I am the customer, not the product dammit.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#29
post #20

It’s a shame the web was so slow to adapt to this new mobile world. When it all started things like offline capabilities were very difficult to do on the web and native development felt necessary. These days the web can actually do a lot… but it’s too late. People expect to find something in the App Store, pinning a web site to their Home Screen is just not something they know they can do. So a lot of people waste an…

I think the web did fine. People can't pin a web app because Apple made it difficult for them to do exactly that.

Re: “It works better in the app”

#30
Hah. I was trying to buy something on the BestBuy website. I’m not sure what kinda of bitcoin miner they’re running on that site, but it repeatedly manages to crash the tab as I was trying to browse. I had to eventually just download the app.
Post reply on HN