Live data from Hacker News

Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

louisabraham.github.io

201–210 of 328 posts

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#201

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You did a fantastic job; very to-the-point with effective visualisations. Kudos! One very minor note: if your scroll device reports pixel-perfect deltas rather than discrete scroll-wheel ticks (e.g. logitech mx master, laptop touchpad, etc), the behaviour in the word search box is a bit weird. Arrow keys work fine though.

Thank you! I did test it with my mac touchpad without issue. Maybe the problem is that I wanted to make discrete scroll-wheel ticks work. I just tried a fix by normalising deltaMode to pixels. If you could just paste this in your console, I would have a better idea: document.querySelector('.wall').addEventListener('wheel', e => console.log(e.deltaMode, e.deltaY.toFixed(2), e.defaultPrevented ? 'PAGE' : 'native'), tru…

FWIW I got a bunch of "(-)10.00 native" in the console, "PAGE" never showed up no matter what I tried. Firefox, also a Logitech mouse, no trackpad though.

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#202

I was pleasantly surprised when I attempted to scroll down and realized everything the author wanted to present fit on-screen. It's almost ironic that this site is able to make such an obvious, compelling presentation without being overly verbose or complicated (something which LLMs have a hard time doing). I wouldn't read TOO deeply into what is being presented, but the author has done a good job to not inject their…

> I suspect, as we continue forward, humans will slowly start to adopt the language of LLMs, or at least certain language quirks that come from interacting with LLMs.

Or we'll do the opposite and even deliberately use some words that an LLM would never use to identify whose content is worth reading?

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#203

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"seam" is a cop-out term for when someone (usually AI) lacks the imagination to come up with something more descriptive. It's like saying "middle thing". Just name it by what it does, and if you can't, remove it because it's not doing anything. "load-bearing" on the other hand is just a weird way to say "required" or "prerequisite" without drawing any attention to the fact that one cannot articulate what something is…

"Seam" has been a thing since before the AI craze. Wasn't it the NSA director who once said something like "we make our living at the seams"?

Not the same thing.

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#204
Interesting response from Claude, when I attempted to reduce the "load-bearing" in its responses:

I added to my global prompt:

- Orwell's first rule: never use a metaphor you're used to seeing in print. "Load-bearing", "the crux", "first-class citizen" signal insight instead of showing it. Name the specific mechanism

when I asked what it thought of the change, its reply was:

The Orwell bullet fights my own system prompt. My harness instructions literally tell me to flag "something load-bearing" when I find it.

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#205

Is it relative frequency of those words or absolute number per PR? Would there be the same tendency of we looked simply at the number of words in a commit/pr? In my case my commit messages are on average 10x shorter than Claude's.

I compute frequencies and rank the words by relative frequency!

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#207
post #204

Interesting response from Claude, when I attempted to reduce the "load-bearing" in its responses: I added to my global prompt: - Orwell's first rule: never use a metaphor you're used to seeing in print. "Load-bearing", "the crux", "first-class citizen" signal insight instead of showing it. Name the specific mechanism when I asked what it thought of the change, its reply was: The Orwell bullet fights my own system pro…

[flagged]

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#208

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You did a fantastic job; very to-the-point with effective visualisations. Kudos! One very minor note: if your scroll device reports pixel-perfect deltas rather than discrete scroll-wheel ticks (e.g. logitech mx master, laptop touchpad, etc), the behaviour in the word search box is a bit weird. Arrow keys work fine though.

On a compatible Logitech device, browsing through the word search box benefits a lot from enabling hyperscroll.

G502 user here! I also put a draggable scrollbar for the less lucky :)

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#209
post #90
post #11

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Author here :) Thank you for the compliment! I did spend a lot of time designing a nice experience on both desktop and mobile. Even the scrollbar to select words was non trivial as I wanted the words to be of different size, yet avoid flickering when scrolling!

Congratulations! I was going to comment on the scroll field in particular when I saw this. I didn't even realize you had to hand-craft the component, but it's such a nice UI idea in general, the way the scrolling works and how the content above changes.

Thanks! The real and probably unnecessary pain was having the words in different sizes.

Re: Show HN: The load-bearing vocabulary of Claude

#210
While the post is specific to Claude, interestingly I found the same terms and language patterns appear noticeably more often in recent Open AI conversations as well. Also in the same timeframe as for the Claude models. And I can see two reasons for that. One being that one company is training on the models of the other company, but I highly doubt that because of the apparent similar appearance without noticeable delay. And the other being that there has been some fundamental realization on how to improve and shape conversations.

I see people around here giving advice on how to reduce this vocabulary in the model output. I’m not certain this is a clever thing to do, as it appears to me, the emphasis on certain words is deliberate, and an important step towards overall quality as the words are being played back to the model in the next turn and thus supporting the model shape its own thoughts and stay on course.

Post reply on HN