Live data from Hacker News

How Universities Should Prepare Founders

paulgraham.com

91–100 of 333 posts

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#91

> Merely eliminating [homework[ for a few weeks resulted in two trillion dollar companies. Imagine what the US GDP would be if reading period at Harvard were twice as long. This idea that "very large company" -> "productive economy" needs to die.

could you explain your perspective more?

i see it as: large companies are proof that much trade and consumption has occurred.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#92

> Merely eliminating [homework[ for a few weeks resulted in two trillion dollar companies. Imagine what the US GDP would be if reading period at Harvard were twice as long. This idea that "very large company" -> "productive economy" needs to die.

could you explain your perspective more? i see it as: large companies are proof that much trade and consumption has occurred.

They are proof monopoly power was captured.

And practically, they are not good for democracy or even economy as such.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#93

> Merely eliminating [homework[ for a few weeks resulted in two trillion dollar companies. Imagine what the US GDP would be if reading period at Harvard were twice as long. This idea that "very large company" -> "productive economy" needs to die.

could you explain your perspective more? i see it as: large companies are proof that much trade and consumption has occurred.

Large companies are more like proof that much concentration of wealth and power has occurred.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#94

99% of university students will never start a company. 99% of those who do will close down without making any measurable difference to the world. I think the world would be better off if the universities actively discouraged the idea of starting companies. Those few who really burn for the idea might do it anyway, and might be more likely to succeed.

I think that undermines a lot of benefits of entrepreneurship - the learning of many different skills, network, etc. and also just the adventure of starting a company.

It’s like saying most people will never be professional athletes so we should discourage sports.

Or most people live in their home country, so we should discourage young people from taking backpacking trips.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#95

> Merely eliminating [homework[ for a few weeks resulted in two trillion dollar companies. Imagine what the US GDP would be if reading period at Harvard were twice as long. This idea that "very large company" -> "productive economy" needs to die.

Large companies provide people with jobs and fund many suppliers with their transactions/operations. Walmart and Amazon are the two biggest employers in the US.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#96
post #61

I don’t necessarily disagree with this but is it the universities job to prepare founders at the expense of everyone else? Under his proposal the motivated founders succeed and everyone else is a loser. This is a very VC focused lens that ignores all the other possible outcomes a human could pursue that are valuable. Established corps need workers, unis need new teachers, hospitals need doctors, etc. So we should let…

> So we should let all those people suffer to promote a small group of founders by reducing course load?

Yes, that is pretty much VC enterprenour philosophy in nutshell. It is value system that value only one small group only. And if that small group has to put in effort into learning in school or doing something other then building unicorns, that is a great unfairness.

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#97
post #43
post #37

I disagree with the underlying assumption that it's the universities responsibility to cultivate founders. Universities were initially built to further the knowledge of specific fields, for the sake of its own advancement, producing philosophers, artists and scientists. In other words, universities are for people to learn for the sake of learning, not to earn a wage. New institutions should be built to cultivate foun…

Although in principle I agree, cultivating founders could be an added mission.

Why, in particular, above any other aspect of society?

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#98

> Merely eliminating [homework[ for a few weeks resulted in two trillion dollar companies. Imagine what the US GDP would be if reading period at Harvard were twice as long. This idea that "very large company" -> "productive economy" needs to die.

could you explain your perspective more? i see it as: large companies are proof that much trade and consumption has occurred.

Big companies like apple or meta screw their home countries (and most other countries, apart from tax havens) dramatically. Basically no taxes paid which is core to how state and everything is financed, have often enough power and huge egos to start meddling with running the state itself. They are utterly selfish entities run by highly functioning sociopaths with no concern about long term wellbeing of population. I could go on and on like this. Yes, some do give nice salaries but apart from faangs in SV its not the rule.

Bunch of smaller companies would have to form some sort of long term cartel and sync those egos to achieve anything close to one major company.

Last thing this world needs is another fuckup trillionaire with massive childhood/mental issues and ego bigger than Everest who thinks he knows where humanity should go (to serve their wishes and needs). Or just milk mankind of anything good remaining like zuckenberg is doing.

I don't need to name further, we can all imagine our own elons on that place

Re: How Universities Should Prepare Founders

#100

I hate the term “founder”. It grossly blurs the distinction between those who put in personal blood, sweat, tears, and money into starting a business versus those who make a few slides so they can use other people’s money to hire others to do all the work and come up with all the ideas.

Honestly, I think we would do well to dispose of both "founder" and "startup".

We had words for this. "Small business" and "Small business owner".

Post reply on HN