Live data from Hacker News

Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

blog.elis.cc

51–60 of 163 posts

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#52
post #7

If you could just change your company's domain name that'd be swell! Surprising Google is happy to lose a paying company over this. Although the author is taking quite the risk bypassing Google's validation like that. Not sure I'd be risking my company's workspace to do it in case Google wakes up ban hammer happy one morning.

Google would rather cheap out on offshore support than waste their engineers' time talking to real customers.

Plus, any entity large enough probably has some kind of account manager or contact in Google that could hopefully escalate to the right person.

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#53

My business Workspace account got suspended recently, no reason given, can’t even login to contact support. I’m a solo user so I only had one admin account and that was the one locked out. There was just one text field to submit an appeal, so I did. I never got any email confirmation or tracking number for my appeal, it’s been a week now with no contact from Google. This happened about a week after they charged my cr…

I got into self hosting in 2021.

A cheap 2.5Gb how from racknerd, $20-22/year, + domain.

It's been as smooth sailing as any other email provider.

Very satisfied.

Try it

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#54

I use a .one for a project where it makes perfect sense. Brevo, who are a huge email delivery platform, told me they don't support signing up with a .one domain. Fortunately, after a couple of weeks going back-and-forth one of their developers eventually saw sense and fixed it. Sadly, with Google, I don't think you'll ever get the issue that far up the chain.

I've got a .email domain which various UK based retailers insist isn't a real domain from which email can be sent. I've been trying to convince Argos that it is real for about seven years.

To their credit, my building society actually took it all on board and fixed their system within a few months. To my incredible surprise, so did a major insurer.

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#55
post #15

I get this sort of thing constantly because my domain, 3e.org, which I have had for 30 years, is apparently impossible. It's either too short to be real, or starts with a number (obviously impossible). And like the author, 90% of the time I can just disable their front-end validation and go on my merry way.

My friend has a short last name, and they still have many websites be like "must be longer then 3 letter"

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#57
I was about to say that the response was pretty clear, e.g, “your domain sounds like spam”, and you can’t give a more clear reasoning for “exactly why” than any other spam filter can give you an “exactly why reason”.

But then I saw the work around at it turned out it was just incompetence compounding.

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#58
post #55
post #15

I get this sort of thing constantly because my domain, 3e.org, which I have had for 30 years, is apparently impossible. It's either too short to be real, or starts with a number (obviously impossible). And like the author, 90% of the time I can just disable their front-end validation and go on my merry way.

My friend has a short last name, and they still have many websites be like "must be longer then 3 letter"

Has your friend tried clearing their cookies?

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#59

The end is really hilarious. Google had a stupid frontend-only validation, it seems.

I was under the impression Google engineers went through a rigorous hiring process, yet this is the sort of thing you get from lowest bidder consultants who have inexperienced devs.

Nah Google and Microsoft have been offshoring to India for years. And sorry, but the developers there suck.

Re: Google Workspace thinks my domain is an email provider (2025)

#60
post #15

I get this sort of thing constantly because my domain, 3e.org, which I have had for 30 years, is apparently impossible. It's either too short to be real, or starts with a number (obviously impossible). And like the author, 90% of the time I can just disable their front-end validation and go on my merry way.

Super cool website btw.. cheers!
Post reply on HN