Live data from Hacker News

Explain it to me like I'm ten

timharford.com

41–50 of 82 posts

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#41

My favorite quote from Mark Twain is “I didn’t have time to write a short letter, so I wrote a long one instead”. Indeed, brevity and clarity actually take time and analysis. I find this to be very true when writing requirements or documentation. Some of the worst requirements I’ve read have been extremely wordy and unnecessarily over-technical or jargon-heavy when it could have been explained in plain language. As u…

[deleted]

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#43

With both ELI5 and this title, the hidden assumption which is generally correct is that "I don't remember much from my education specifically middle and highschool". Well I do remember my highschool subjects and I feel like there is a chasm between highly detailed technical content created for other profesionals and watered down versions for 5 year olds. I don't see that many "explain to me like I've finished highsch…

I think at some point you just have to try to read the technical content then see what you don't understand and figure that out.

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#44

With both ELI5 and this title, the hidden assumption which is generally correct is that "I don't remember much from my education specifically middle and highschool". Well I do remember my highschool subjects and I feel like there is a chasm between highly detailed technical content created for other profesionals and watered down versions for 5 year olds. I don't see that many "explain to me like I've finished highsch…

You're asking for "explain like you respect my intelligence"

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#45
post #33

"puzzling than pellucid" Pellucid might be cromullant but it ain't pervasive. I have never heard that word and I've heard quite a few. If I had to guess: it might be American (US) in situ wankery only, for the use of. Might be wrong.

Harford, the author of the OC, is a learned man of at least middle-age (sorry!). He has been a journalist for decades. I suspect he may have had an education including Latin (per-lucid => pellucid) making that word choice far more natural. But really it's a poetic pairing of punchy adjectives amplified by alliteration! I'm a fan of his work generally. This piece landed well with me, I like to read less used vocabular…

> But really it's a poetic pairing of punchy adjectives amplified by alliteration!

Silence! You bubble-headed boobie!

-- Dr. Smith

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#46

With both ELI5 and this title, the hidden assumption which is generally correct is that "I don't remember much from my education specifically middle and highschool". Well I do remember my highschool subjects and I feel like there is a chasm between highly detailed technical content created for other profesionals and watered down versions for 5 year olds. I don't see that many "explain to me like I've finished highsch…

I used to work in higher ed. The reason you don't see this is that it's harder to produce (usably) than an eli5; there is little incentive as there aren't many advanced enough to want it who aren't also in walled off training; and there are often many tiers between layperson and professional such that connecting the right audience with the right material is its own problem. I agree it is terribly frustrating.

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#47
post #32

Earlier quoted context omitted.

... 5 years prior

Well I've got 38 years of reading experience and have never seen that word.

If you can't glean the definition from context, anyone 10 years old or older should be able to use a dictionary.

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#49

With both ELI5 and this title, the hidden assumption which is generally correct is that "I don't remember much from my education specifically middle and highschool". Well I do remember my highschool subjects and I feel like there is a chasm between highly detailed technical content created for other profesionals and watered down versions for 5 year olds. I don't see that many "explain to me like I've finished highsch…

I teach OS security for a masters course. I don't know where my students are for any given semester - it's a mixture between experts who need a certification (I have taught someone who literally wrote the book on a major OS's security model) and people who have ended up on security entirely by accident. It is extremely hard to write something that lands for that entire range. "Finished highschool" is really not a precise determinator in the way "I am literally 5" is.

Re: Explain it to me like I'm ten

#50

With both ELI5 and this title, the hidden assumption which is generally correct is that "I don't remember much from my education specifically middle and highschool". Well I do remember my highschool subjects and I feel like there is a chasm between highly detailed technical content created for other profesionals and watered down versions for 5 year olds. I don't see that many "explain to me like I've finished highsch…

You're asking for "explain like you respect my intelligence"

I think OPs comment is about education and not intelligence per se.
Post reply on HN