Live data from Hacker News

A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

decodingvibes.com

61–70 of 113 posts

Re: A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

#63

I would thoroughly enjoy an entire podcast of this genre. ... A Cartesian Critique of "Fireflies" by Owl City ... A Humean Critique of "I Gotta Feeling" by The Black Eyed Peas

Then ask an LLM. I'm serious, if you like the style. This article, despite the disclaimer, is almost certainly LLM-written. It's one of many ephemeral blogs that have been cropping up on HN lately and that post single-theme content with striking regularity.

Re: A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

#64

Earlier quoted context omitted.

First rule of relationships: adhere to the first rule of improv!

I had a coworker who talked all the time about their improv activities outside of work. They also dropped “yes, and” into business meetings with execs, and would then explain why. They asked me if I thought it would be a fun team-building exercise to bring in their improv coach and do a class with a bunch of VPs and directors. I said no. I understand the concept but sometimes people can be overzealous about their pas…

What?! I think a 28 hour game of Twilight Imperium would be a great team destroying exercise.

Re: A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

#68
> We cannot attribute any moral judgment to Bieber as a human being; we can only answer the moral question as posed in the song.

As a semi-off-topic little rant, why do we always assume that pop singers are singing about themselves and their own experiences? Can a song, as a work of art, not have an independent existence, much as a novel may? Pop, rap, and maybe country songs are all now assumed to be about the artist themselves.

Re: A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

#69
post #37

This 3 minute song creates a fleeting portrait of a man, not necessarily Bieber, who we cannot know. The song captures the mindset of a character who, one might infer, cynically knows what he’s trying to do. It’s possible he has no interest in a heartfelt, meaningful apology. In fact, this character - who lives only within the song and the liminal world it creates - may be operating exactly to his own moral preferenc…

> you Kant analyze pop music with confidence

Fun fact: The correct German pronunciation of “Kant” isn’t like “can’t”, but like “cunt”.

Re: A Kantian Critique of "Sorry" by Justin Bieber

#70

> We cannot attribute any moral judgment to Bieber as a human being; we can only answer the moral question as posed in the song. As a semi-off-topic little rant, why do we always assume that pop singers are singing about themselves and their own experiences? Can a song, as a work of art, not have an independent existence, much as a novel may? Pop, rap, and maybe country songs are all now assumed to be about the artis…

Last time at a karaoke I sang a song that translates to "we're hitchhiking".

Little did the audience know that I wasn't hitchhiking at all and neither were they. I was just standing there, singing.

Post reply on HN